If you had to choose only one guy who would you pick? Soto, Acuna or Tatis?

[Wrigs37]

Easy answer is Tatis. Trout told you last year. Goats recognize other goats...

Ignore my sig

[sportsfan12345]

Acuna and its not close. Well Soto is a semi-close second lol. Tatis is far from them based on advanced stats that I've seen. Overall, they are all great players.

Acuna > Soto > Tatis

[comicbooksgo]

That's a good point. Wasn't Robles hyped up like crazy coming into 2018? I could have sworn that he was the "It" guy ahead of Soto if my memory serves. That's definitely flipped since then. What's Robles problem? Playing through injuries? Just overrated to start with? I don't remember anything significant pertaining to him in any of the games I saw with the Nats..

Originally Posted by brewtown107

Lol! I don't know who Acuna's gf is, but I'll grant you that one anyway.

I think Robles was supposed to be Soto's sidekick, but he needs to get his sh!t together. Albies definitely has him beat by a mile!

[pewe]

Originally Posted by comicbooksgo

That's a good point. Wasn't Robles hyped up like crazy coming into 2018? I could have sworn that he was the "It" guy ahead of Soto if my memory serves. That's definitely flipped since then. What's Robles problem? Playing through injuries? Just overrated to start with? I don't remember anything significant pertaining to him in any of the games I saw with the Nats..

Weak at the plate


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[HRBELLI2017]

Bellinger...

If I had the rank the 3 you chose.
Soto
Tatis
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
acuna

[comicbooksgo]

Agreed.

Originally Posted by HRBELLI2017

Bellinger...

If I had the rank the 3 you chose.
Soto
Tatis
and now a drum roll for the number 1, America's sweetheart...
.

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Acuna!

[cardmole]

Originally Posted by sportsfan12345

Acuna and its not close. Well Soto is a semi-close second lol. Tatis is far from them based on advanced stats that I've seen. Overall, they are all great players.

Acuna > Soto > Tatis

Nuff said....

[pewe]

Not enough cards pics in this thread






Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[speedyjg13]

Originally Posted by brewtown107

Soto. Obviously.

Acuna will never hit 3 home runs in the World Series in his age 20 season. Acuna has never even been to the World Series.

Soto will never put up a 40/40 season, but then again, Acuna hasn't done that either. Funny how so much of Acuna's hype comes from something he failed to actually do.

Soto is a story. Exciting! He's got elite command of the strike zone, and he'll let you know it. The Soto shuffle gets people talking. It's proof positive that Soto doesn't lack for swagger.

Soto came up huge in huge moments in the playoffs. He sent Milwaukee home with a huge hit, and kept the hits rolling from there.

Who can change the momentum of a World Series game with one swing on one pitch thrown in the game? Not Acuna. Again, he needs to get to a World Series first. Meanwhile, Soto has already done this:



Soto wins. Mic drop.

Very compelling argument here

Disclaimer:I dont own a single card of Tatis, Soto, Acuna

[HRBELLI2017]

Originally Posted by comicbooksgo

Agreed.

Actually Acuna at the bottom of the ladder.
So far for 2020 he batted .138 with -0-HR 14KO in 29 at bats.
Such superior results against mostly pitchers trying to get into the big league.

Even Chris Davis made him look bad.

[comicbooksgo]

He was merely lulling the league into a false sense of security; waiting for the moment to strike. Plus everyone knows that there only so many HR's in any given bat. Why waste them in ST? He's frugal. Another plus.

Originally Posted by HRBELLI2017

Actually Acuna at the bottom of the ladder.
So far for 2020 he batted .138 with -0-HR 14KO in 29 at bats.
Such superior results against mostly pitchers trying to get into the big league.

Even Chris Davis made him look bad.

[SaltyCracker]

Originally Posted by HRBELLI2017

Actually Acuna at the bottom of the ladder.
So far for 2020 he batted .138 with -0-HR 14KO in 29 at bats.
Such superior results against mostly pitchers trying to get into the big league.

Even Chris Davis made him look bad.

In 2018 Spring Training Jason Kipnis hit 6hrs in 52ab ......

[OPCB]

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[pewe]

Originally Posted by OPCB

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I bow down to you!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[HRBELLI2017]

Originally Posted by OPCB

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Awesome card.
I can see that being worth carp er I mean Trout like dollars in a handful of years but if it's a PC card definitely the Top card to have.

[brewtown107]

Originally Posted by comicbooksgo

That's a good point. Wasn't Robles hyped up like crazy coming into 2018? I could have sworn that he was the "It" guy ahead of Soto if my memory serves. That's definitely flipped since then. What's Robles problem? Playing through injuries? Just overrated to start with? I don't remember anything significant pertaining to him in any of the games I saw with the Nats..

Yep, you remember that correctly. Soto was thought to be a year or two away from the bigs in going into 2018. Robles was the big name prospect, ahead of Soto in the pecking order. Soto was called up in the summer of '18 instead of Robles only because Robles was hurt at the time. Robles' speed and defense has been there, but he needs to get dialed in better at the plate. He's still a productive player, but not a star.

Meanwhile, I think Albies is a legit star in his own right. As a Brewers fan, I see him as the Paul Molitor to Acuna's Robin Yount.

[REGGIE206]

Originally Posted by brewtown107

Soto. Obviously.

Acuna will never hit 3 home runs in the World Series in his age 20 season. Acuna has never even been to the World Series.

Soto will never put up a 40/40 season, but then again, Acuna hasn't done that either. Funny how so much of Acuna's hype comes from something he failed to actually do.

Soto is a story. Exciting! He's got elite command of the strike zone, and he'll let you know it. The Soto shuffle gets people talking. It's proof positive that Soto doesn't lack for swagger.

Soto came up huge in huge moments in the playoffs. He sent Milwaukee home with a huge hit, and kept the hits rolling from there.

Who can change the momentum of a World Series game with one swing on one pitch thrown in the game? Not Acuna. Again, he needs to get to a World Series first. Meanwhile, Soto has already done this:



Soto wins. Mic drop.

Shut down the thread! /thread

[speedyjg13]

it's currently looking like

Soto > Tatis > Acuna

Ronnie getting left behind

Disclaimer: I don't own cards of any of the 3

[BBases31]

With Tatis' injury history, Soto is a no brainer

[KhalDrogo]

Originally Posted by KhalDrogo

To have on my team? Soto.

To own cards of? Acuna.

Soto’s YoY improvement despite the weird season and Rendon being gone may make me change my mind

[ThoseBackPages]

BuY THEM ALL!!!!!!!!

[Zauron]

Originally Posted by ThoseBackPages

BuY THEM ALL!!!!!!!!

I would do this, but it's looking more like Khal said.

Soto, Tatis, Acuna.

Someone else mentioned Bellinger...Bellinger looks so lost out there.

[Trueblue]

I don't see how you don't take the dude that led his team to the WS and has the best bat and plate discipline. At present, Soto is like a surgical scalpel vs tatis/acuna being a jack hammer.

[BraveAtlanta]

1. Acuna is the whole package
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
2. Soto - has some pop and walks more
.
3. Tatis - very exciting start

[pewe]

Originally Posted by KhalDrogo

Soto’s YoY improvement despite the weird season and Rendon being gone may make me change my mind

It is super super impressive


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk