Would you make this high-end Trade??????

[upsheez]

I have been offered both attached files below...

AND $300...




For this...

Would you do it?

[chitownbears22]

Just my opinion, but that Jordan label looks a little odd.

[JMG318]

Jordan label def looks off

[Donkaylove]

Yup---all day every day

[asujbl]

I'd definitely do that

[tnarg]

Originally Posted by Donkaylove

Yup---all day every day

Originally Posted by asujbl

I'd definitely do that

Yep. Not even sure why you posted the thread. Do it to it.

[pejc300]

Basically you're getting offered $3,000 for the Luck. If it's worth it to you then do it.

[browning51]

yeah, especially after yesterday. Jordans are liquid. hell, break it out of that case and send it to BGS. lol comes back a 8.5 you are looking at 1500-2000.

[chitownbears22]

Did you run a Redlaser on the barcode? Verification number labels can be faked, and there are quite a few PSA 8 Jordans out there. I would ask for higher res photos, the fact that the Jordan is taken at an angle is a RED FLAG.

[crac0018]

Seems to be heavily weighted in your favor. At the very least, I'd be skeptical.

Tell him to sell the Jordan and Montana on his own and then make you a good offer.

Too many stories out there of fake PSA Jordans to make me feel good about this sort of deal. Especially this thread, which shows a letter from PSA stating the graded card was a fake:
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Sports.../td-p/22985341

http://www.blowoutcards.com/forums/b...-now-geez.html

[bradsholly]

Originally Posted by pejc300

Basically you're getting offered $3,000 for the Luck. If it's worth it to you then do it.

wanna buy some cards?

[upsheez]

Originally Posted by pejc300

Basically you're getting offered $3,000 for the Luck. If it's worth it to you then do it.

$3,000????? You came up with that number how?

You are way off...

[pejc300]

Originally Posted by upsheez

$3,000????? You came up with that number how?

You are way off...

My fault - I thought some PSA 8 Jordans were getting around $2200 but I must have misremembered. What are they getting - like $1500?

So, $500 for the Montana, $300 cash, and then whatever the Jordan's are getting.

[upsheez]

Originally Posted by pejc300

My fault - I thought some PSA 8 Jordans were getting around $2200 but I must have misremembered. What are they getting - like $1500?

So, $500 for the Montana, $300 cash, and then whatever the Jordan's are getting.

All good. They are going for aroound $1,300 on ebay but one just sold for $1,050 on here last week. I was putting it around $1,200 mark, Montana around $400ish and $300 cash. So aroound $1,900-$2K.

I'm just concerned about the Jordan. It also concerns me shipping it, etc. This is not a card I can look at in person which may cause me to not commit even though it seems like a good deal...

[pejc300]

Originally Posted by upsheez

All good. They are going for aroound $1,300 on ebay but one just sold for $1,050 on here last week. I was putting it around $1,200 mark, Montana around $400ish and $300 cash. So aroound $1,900-$2K.

I'm just concerned about the Jordan. It also concerns me shipping it, etc. This is not a card I can look at in person which may cause me to not commit even though it seems like a good deal...

Okay, that make sense and makes the decision much tougher in my opinion. I don't think that Luck will ultimately be one of his best cards. I know they are very rare, but I do think the sticker auto affects its bottom line down the road. Not so much because it's a sticker, but because all of the other Luck cards from 2012 Chrome are on-card. And, there are also on-card versions of that base version too. From that standpoint I don't think the card has a ton of room to grow. Montana BGS 9's are on their way up, Jordan PSA 8's are on their way up (although not as much as I thought, I guess).

The Jordan in question here has very good eye appeal. I agree it is prudent to always be concerned about a Jordan RC in a PSA case as there are thousands of frauds. Maybe if you did agree it would be contingent on the other person shipping first and you seeing the Jordan in person before shipping your end? Are you familiar with '86 Fleer cards? If not you could be a lot of commons for a few bucks to compare the Jordan to when you get it.

I would have put your Luck at $1800 - $2000 so I think overall it's fairly even. Good luck with whatever you do and again sorry for the gross overvaluation on the Jordan - totally my fault.

[upsheez]

Originally Posted by pejc300

Okay, that make sense and makes the decision much tougher in my opinion. I don't think that Luck will ultimately be one of his best cards. I know they are very rare, but I do think the sticker auto affects its bottom line down the road. Not so much because it's a sticker, but because all of the other Luck cards from 2012 Chrome are on-card. And, there are also on-card versions of that base version too. From that standpoint I don't think the card has a ton of room to grow. Montana BGS 9's are on their way up, Jordan PSA 8's are on their way up (although not as much as I thought, I guess).

The Jordan in question here has very good eye appeal. I agree it is prudent to always be concerned about a Jordan RC in a PSA case as there are thousands of frauds. Maybe if you did agree it would be contingent on the other person shipping first and you seeing the Jordan in person before shipping your end? Are you familiar with '86 Fleer cards? If not you could be a lot of commons for a few bucks to compare the Jordan to when you get it.

I would have put your Luck at $1800 - $2000 so I think overall it's fairly even. Good luck with whatever you do and again sorry for the gross overvaluation on the Jordan - totally my fault.

Thanks for this. Very helpful! I think it's fairly even too, just want to make sure that card checks out. Thanks for your post in my BKB poll thread too.

To everyone else...here's the new thread I created which also has a pic of the back of the card. Thanks in advance for everyone's help.

http://www.blowoutcards.com/forums/b...ml#post9839620

[No 1]

Use a middleman so he doesn't get to keep your card if his is fake