BGS 9.5 vs PSA 9

[JWBlue]

Same card....

A BGS 9.5 sells for $1,000

A PSA 9 sells for _______


Part 2:

A PSA 10 sells for $2,000

A PSA 9 sells for _______

[JWBlue]

An average BGS 9.5. Not all 9.5.

[RufussCkingston]

Depends on the card.

[Jichael Mordan]

agree it depends on the card. BGS is easier on corners and harder on centering. PSA is harder on corners and easier on centering. my opinion only. If you have a 8 corner with BGS your card will not be higher than a PSA 8 no matter what.

[BiggNuttz]

Originally Posted by JWBlue

Same card....

A BGS 9.5 sells for $1,000

A PSA 9 sells for _______


Part 2:

A PSA 10 sells for $2,000

A PSA 9 sells for _______

As was already mentioned twice, it really does depend on the card. Having said that, right here, right now in September 2024:

BGS 9.5 non True Gem will sell pretty close to the PSA 9 in price, with maybe a slight premium. BGS 9.5s have really fallen a LOT in the market over the past 12~24 months.

PSA 9 vs. PSA 10 is much more difficult. In general, the normal 9>>>10 premium will be 2X-3X, so a $2,000 PSA 10 will see the PSA 9 selling for $650~$1,000. Having said that, for conditionally sensitive cards, with low GEM rates, the multiplier can easily jump up to 6X~10X or more. For modern cards think of things like Messi 71BIS or any numbered base set colour parallels from Topps 2020 Chrome F1 that had all of the edge issues. There are almost no PSA 10's on those so just throw any multiplier out the window.

You should also never ignore the impact that the PSA set registry can have on cards. Look at what some of the Pop 1/Pop 2 1986 Fleer Basketball PSA 10 commons sell for Or another great example would be the 1980 Topps Baseball Rickey Henderson Rookie #482. 37,000++ cards graded, 25 PSA 10's. Fancy a guess on that multiplier?

Regards

[dribbler]

Depends. I know PSA 9 cards that outsell a BGS 9.5 by x2