Super Rare Arod Autograph Error Question 1:614,088 Packs

[luck15hope]

Originally Posted by WilsonValdez

Sorry, but I don't think you know a guy "like him". David would never do any of those things your guy did....There is only 1 David Peters...he is a man unto himself. His complexity can not be explained through simple message board postings.

OP Daydreaming . . . . .

[jlzinck]

Originally Posted by davepeters239;3892255[B

]Can people stop cluttering this post with nonsense[/B] so that those of us who are interested in this can have a nice discussion.

Like this whole thread?

[luck15hope]

OP pondering about making this thread . . .

[pnft17]

Originally Posted by davepeters239

This card is still in its BGS case and i think is an 8 or an 8.5

Did you get it graded or did you buy it already graded?

Can you show it. Does BGS say it's error on case name plate

[MetDude]

Originally Posted by davepeters239

I think if there are more than one and it is proven it is not I am who in the wrong but Topps.

translation please ?

[Imac7065]

Originally Posted by MetDude

translation please ?

He's saying more or less what everyone else did.. it's a topps error and he's trying to insinuate it's supposed to be a 1/1..which it is not

[davepeters239]

Originally Posted by pnft17

Did you get it graded or did you buy it already graded?

Can you show it. Does BGS say it's error on case name plate

I bought it already graded. I collect errors and didn't realize what this error was until after I had it in my possession at which time I thought this was one error I wanted fixed.

I thought I had a scan of it in the case but I guess I do not. The card is not here with me right now but from what I can remember the label does mention it missing the autograph or something like that.

I will get a scan of the card in the BGS case when I can and post it it.

[luck15hope]

Originally Posted by Imac7065

He's saying more or less what everyone else did.. it's a topps error and he's trying to insinuate it's supposed to be a 1/1..which it is not

What or who is making the OP think this card is supposed to be a 1/1 in the first place?

[Imac7065]

Originally Posted by luck15hope

What or who is making the OP think this card is supposed to be a 1/1 in the first place?

*shrugs shoulders*... just my interpretation

[davepeters239]

2005 Bowman Chrome Baseball Box - Complete Set Checklist


Autograph Parallel Cards
- All Cards Are Refractors - Print Run Shown Below -

A-Rod Throwback Autographs #94AR 1994 SF #1/1
A-Rod Throwback Autographs #95AR 1995 XF #/25
A-Rod Throwback Autographs #96AR 1996 RF #/50
A-Rod Throwback Autographs #97AR 1997 CH #/99

[pnft17]

Originally Posted by davepeters239

I bought it already graded. I collect errors and didn't realize what this error was until after I had it in my possession at which time I thought this was one error I wanted fixed.

I thought I had a scan of it in the case but I guess I do not. The card is not here with me right now but from what I can remember the label does mention it missing the autograph or something like that.

I will get a scan of the card in the BGS case when I can and post it it.

Cool, post it when you can

[petesahuttt]

Originally Posted by davepeters239

2005 Bowman Chrome Baseball Box - Complete Set Checklist


Autograph Parallel Cards
- All Cards Are Refractors - Print Run Shown Below -

A-Rod Throwback Autographs #94AR 1994 SF #1/1
A-Rod Throwback Autographs #95AR 1995 XF #/25
A-Rod Throwback Autographs #96AR 1996 RF #/50
A-Rod Throwback Autographs #97AR 1997 CH #/99

Your card does not appear to be a refractor

[37Jetson]

What did you pay for it Mr. Rockefeller?

Originally Posted by davepeters239

I bought it already graded.

[davepeters239]

Originally Posted by petesahuttt

Your card does not appear to be a refractor

That is the only card it could be I think.

[Aleister]

Originally Posted by davepeters239

The reason I think the sticker thing would be ok is because Topps has told me in the past the stickers and the numbers on them have no meaning.

I have two cards serial numbered and autographed both serial nunmbered 1 of 19 a both the exact same card. So when I asked to verfy the cards with the holgram sticker on the back I was told they couldn't and like I mentioned the numbers on the hologram didn't mean anything.

To me the card wouldn't be complete without the stickers and since the stickers don't mean anything to Topps it shouldn't matter?

I guess this is why they stopped putting the holograms on their cards.

You are wrong. First off and most importantly the auto would NOT be a TOPPS autograph. It would be and ONLY be a IP auto. Second it would be an ALTERED card because YOU put a sticker on NOT Topps and the sticker was from a DIFFERENT card whether or not the #s mean anything AND the auto was IP and not sent DIRECTLY from Arod. Sorry NO way around it. Your card will never be anything more than an IP auto if you ever get ity signed. Report me if the truth stings.

[hche]

Originally Posted by Aleister

You are wrong. First off and most importantly the auto would NOT be a TOPPS autograph. It would be and ONLY be a IP auto. Second it would be an ALTERED card because YOU put a sticker on NOT Topps and the sticker was from a DIFFERENT card whether or not the #s mean anything AND the auto was IP and not sent DIRECTLY from Arod. Sorry NO way around it. Your card will never be anything more than an IP auto if you ever get ity signed. Report me if the truth stings.

Perfect post from a new member. Welcome to the board.

[armyatc22]

Originally Posted by davepeters239

That is the only card it could be I think.

You think????

It's slabbed in a BGS case what does it say it is?

Show a full scan

[duwal]

Originally Posted by davepeters239

2005 Bowman Chrome Baseball Box - Complete Set Checklist


Autograph Parallel Cards
- All Cards Are Refractors - Print Run Shown Below -

A-Rod Throwback Autographs #94AR 1994 SF #1/1
A-Rod Throwback Autographs #95AR 1995 XF #/25
A-Rod Throwback Autographs #96AR 1996 RF #/50
A-Rod Throwback Autographs #97AR 1997 CH #/99

The 1/1 stated here I believe is for the Superfractor (SF), like the other ones down the list are for that years xfractor and refractor versions

[petesahuttt]

Originally Posted by davepeters239

That is the only card it could be I think.

Here's my theory on the card. It was supposed to be a refractor, the first printing was botched and they fixed it before pack-out. The card you have was most likely backdoored.
Other possibility is the reprinted non-auto version was erroneously printed with the auto logo and sticker spots.
In any case, I would honestly give up hoping that Topps will fix this or even care about this card you have. I can't see being indignant if you weren't the one who pulled the card.

[Aleister]

Originally Posted by hche

Perfect post from a new member. Welcome to the board.

Thank you.

[armyatc22]

According to the pop report that card isn't even graded so that's not the card you have

[armyatc22]

/end thread

[Imac7065]

Originally Posted by armyatc22

According to the pop report that card isn't even graded so that's not the card you have

that pop report says 12 were graded actually? lol.. so much for a 1/1

[davepeters239]

Originally Posted by Aleister

You are wrong. First off and most importantly the auto would NOT be a TOPPS autograph. It would be and ONLY be a IP auto. Second it would be an ALTERED card because YOU put a sticker on NOT Topps and the sticker was from a DIFFERENT card whether or not the #s mean anything AND the auto was IP and not sent DIRECTLY from Arod. Sorry NO way around it. Your card will never be anything more than an IP auto if you ever get ity signed. Report me if the truth stings.

Why would I report you

I have tried my best to get this card corrected. Topps won't fix it, Beckett won't acknowledge it as an error. Arod's friend or agent or wheoever I spoke to was the only cool person in all of this and really wanted to help fix it.

If I do get it autographed and get stickers placed on it I will be very honest about all of that when I sell it.

Like I said it is very easy for people to poke fun but I suspect if some here had a card with the odds to pull at over a half a million and a 1 of 1 they wouldn't think it so funny.

I have started to sell off my cards to maybe get a car for my mom and because the hobby is no fun anymore. You have card companies doing all sorts of shady things and then you have to deal with some of the mean people who have cluttered this thread with nonsense.

[luck15hope]

Originally Posted by Imac7065

that pop report says 12 were graded actually? lol.. so much for a 1/1

Does that pop report include the autographed versions??