⛏⛏⛏ The Official 2025 San Francisco 49ers Thread: Return of the Purdi ⛏⛏⛏

[jacksonjj]

Originally Posted by 49erRCCollector

The playoff W/L is a team thing.

Jimmy never sniffed a pro bowl, never an MVP candidate, not the same QB as Brock.

Let's say focused.

no joke. Purdy led the league in QBR last season and beat Mahomes again this year with a never ending rotation of injuries on offense. Comparisons to Jimmy are baffling.

[SleeperCards]

Originally Posted by jacksonjj

no joke. Purdy led the league in QBR last season and beat Mahomes again this year with a never ending rotation of injuries on offense. Comparisons to Jimmy are baffling.

It fuels herman o's hate boner.

[Jaysabz]

Originally Posted by hermanotarjeta

You need money to create a well-balanced team.

Niners don’t have to put that much into the QB position to win.

Don’t become the Dallas Cowboys of the west coast.

What makes the 49ers any different than every other team in the NFL? Why do the 49ers have to spend half or less than most other teams on QB when other teams can win with spending 40-50m on a QB?

Maybe cut bait with some diva WRs who didn't produce much. Cut defensive players who aren't pulling their weight.

Maybe it's time to move on from CMC - does he have any gas left in the tank with as much he's been leaned on? The guy played four games this year and had 0 TDs after signing a two-year, $38 million contract extension with the San Francisco 49ers in June, right before camp.

They need to make some hard personnel decisions, get some players in the 2025 draft that can contribute right away, and pay someone to play QB.

[jdandns]

Originally Posted by Floridacardguy

But Aaron Rodgers sucks. If you let Purdy walk but replace him with a washed and old Rodgers, how does that help SF during the small window of opportunity?

Rodgers says that he'll be at least three years younger next season, and I believe him.

[Delta5]

Originally Posted by 49erRCCollector

The playoff W/L is a team thing.

Jimmy never sniffed a pro bowl, never an MVP candidate, not the same QB as Brock.

Let's say focused.

People on mahomes thread would argue otherwise

[Delta5]

Originally Posted by jacksonjj

no joke. Purdy led the league in QBR last season and beat Mahomes again this year with a never ending rotation of injuries on offense. Comparisons to Jimmy are baffling.

Not that hard to beat Mahomes QBR these days tbh

[hermanotarjeta]

Originally Posted by Jaysabz

What makes the 49ers any different than every other team in the NFL? Why do the 49ers have to spend half or less than most other teams on QB when other teams can win with spending 40-50m on a QB?

Maybe cut bait with some diva WRs who didn't produce much. Cut defensive players who aren't pulling their weight.

Maybe it's time to move on from CMC - does he have any gas left in the tank with as much he's been leaned on? The guy played four games this year and had 0 TDs after signing a two-year, $38 million contract extension with the San Francisco 49ers in June, right before camp.

They need to make some hard personnel decisions, get some players in the 2025 draft that can contribute right away, and pay someone to play QB.

The rest of the Niners roster has benefited from an extremely team-friendly QB contract. Throw off that balance and the Niners can’t keep many of their weapons, and Purdy hasn’t shown he can win without them.

The Niners are in position to win NOW, not everyone in the league is in the same situation. CMC enhances Purdy’s game significantly. Losing CMC and/or Deebo/Kittle at the expense of Purdy could be fatal to their playoff chances for the next decade.

[Athey49]

Wow, a lot of 49er fans here!

[49erRCCollector]

Originally Posted by Athey49

Wow, a lot of 49er fans here!

Just thinking: page 4 in two days for a 2025 49ers thread.

The sun never sets on The Empire.

[SleeperCards]

Originally Posted by Athey49

Wow, a lot of 49er fans here!

I'm just a Purdvert. I also think the 49ers could be back in the SB a lot sooner than others are projecting.

[49ersSF]

I'm projecting they will make another Super Bowl appearance in 7 to 10 years.

[hermanotarjeta]

Originally Posted by 49ersSF

I'm projecting they will make another Super Bowl appearance in 7 to 10 years.

Will their QB be Purdy, another current QB or a future NFL player when they do?

[BonVoyage]

Originally Posted by Boo

The problem is that you can't pay him $50M and still have the highest paid RB, LT and DE in the league on your team. Well you can but you'll have scrub backups. As we've seen this year, injuries happen to every team and if it happens to the 49ers with that setup, they won't be making it back to the SB anytime soon.

You left out highest paid FB, #5 and #14 WRs, #3 TE, #2 ILB, #12 and #15 CB… Niners have high priced players all over the roster. There needs to be significant reallocation if they pay Purdy $60M.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[jacksonjj]

Originally Posted by SleeperCards

I'm just a Purdvert. I also think the 49ers could be back in the SB a lot sooner than others are projecting.

Seriously it's going to be next year. I'm not sure what all the fuss is about.

Their schedule is the easiest schedule I've seen a team have maybe ever.

[49erRCCollector]

Originally Posted by jacksonjj

Seriously it's going to be next year. I'm not sure what all the fuss is about.

Their schedule is the easiest schedule I've seen a team have maybe ever.

on paper that schedule should be a cakewalk. They still need to get Brock settled and be smart in this draft.

Truth is they have been less effective against the run since Buckner left and with Armstead gone the run D has gone in the toilet. The interior of that D Line needs SERIOUS help.

[49ersSF]

Originally Posted by hermanotarjeta

Will their QB be Purdy, another current QB or a future NFL player when they do?

I think Purdy will become untradeable once he signs the contract. He'll probably be out by 2027 for not living up to the contract. They will go through a 4 year period where they sign QB castaways like Anthony Richardson, Daniel Jones, Bryce Young, Kyler Murray. By 2031, 49erRCC will have exhausted all the possible Star Wars thread names option and the niners will start to have an upswing.

[49erRCCollector]

Originally Posted by 49ersSF

I think Purdy will become untradeable once he signs the contract. He'll probably be out by 2027 for not living up to the contract. They will go through a 4 year period where they sign QB castaways like Anthony Richardson, Daniel Jones, Bryce Young, Kyler Murray. By 2031, 49erRCC will have exhausted all the possible Star Wars thread names option and the niners will start to have an upswing.

You're making me want to SW harder.

[patchgenie]

do you guys know why tanner Mordecai has no cards?

[Athey49]

Welcome back Mr. Saleh!

[BonVoyage]

Griese chose to walk away from coaching. Seemed like he did a solid job as QB coach. Wish him well.

Curious how this draft plays out. Our best hope is Ward, Sanders, McMillan, and Jenty go in the top 10, pushing down a player that wouldn't otherwise be there at 11. If that happens, we should have our choice between a top 2 OT, top 2 DL, Tyler Warren, or Will Johnson. Or we could trade back - saw one GM say there's only 4-5 difference makers in the draft then its a bunch of solid starters, Niners could decide to trade back and acquire more picks if there isn't much difference between player 11 and player 20-30.

[Floridacardguy]

Purdy about to get PAID $$$$

[mjekase]

Originally Posted by BonVoyage

If that happens, we should have our choice between a top 2 OT, top 2 DL, Tyler Warren, or Will Johnson. Or we could trade back - saw one GM say there's only 4-5 difference makers in the draft then its a bunch of solid starters, Niners could decide to trade back and acquire more picks if there isn't much difference between player 11 and player 20-30.

Given the supposed depth at D-Line, this sounds like a smart/plausible move, as they can move back to around 20, still get a good O-Lineman, and add a couple picks to bolster the Defensive front.

[Jaysabz]

Originally Posted by 49erRCCollector

on paper that schedule should be a cakewalk. They still need to get Brock settled and be smart in this draft.

Truth is they have been less effective against the run since Buckner left and with Armstead gone the run D has gone in the toilet. The interior of that D Line needs SERIOUS help.

It's going to be interesting year.

The NFC West plays the NFC South and the AFC South - both arguably the weakest divisions in their conferences.

The NFC North and NFC East have it tough - they play each other, then the NFC North Plays the AFC North, while the NFC East plays the AFC West.

NFC South plays the NFC West and the AFC East.

I think the playoff race is going to be tight in the NFC.

[BonVoyage]

Originally Posted by mjekase

Given the supposed depth at D-Line, this sounds like a smart/plausible move, as they can move back to around 20, still get a good O-Lineman, and add a couple picks to bolster the Defensive front.

A couple trades that line up according to the Jimmy Johnson draft pick value chart:

If niners want to trade down (if they don't see much difference between player 11 and 20)
SF gets pick 20 and 51
DEN gets pick 11

If niners want to trade up (if a difference maker slips to 8)
SF gets pick 8
CAR gets pick 11, 99, & 138

The knock I've heard for the top OT prospects is they're kind of tackle/guard tweeners. If that's the case, not sure the Niners will use a high pick on someone who could be a Guard.

[tjforce]

9ers have to be one of the most interesting teams this season:

Their top end talent, is elite, but old. Williams, McCaffrey, Kittle, Samuel, Floyd.... lethal if all healthy, but injury prone.

It's a team that has a legit shot at getting a Super Bowl, but also a legit shot and wanting to blow it up at some point very soon. But what it looks like is they'll run it back at least one more season.