Buyer Beware - Spreadsheet list of Altered, Fake, or Mislabeled Cards

[DragonWagon]

Originally Posted by JimEd14

Seems like these are the types of thing this database tracks, a PSA mislabel.

2014 Mookie Betts - Labeled as "Batting - Clear" but it's not.

PSA Cert HERE says clear.

Pics from the ebay auction that just ended attached, not clear:

Added to the database:

Mislabeled 2014 Mookie Betts #US-26 Topps Update - Batting - Clear PSA 10 cert# 42383401 is NOT clear

[DragonWagon]

Originally Posted by Bruins1993

Thanks! Any total tally's (# of cards, mkt value) to date on the database?

For 2024 I added 934 cards sold for over $1.2 Million

In total: there are 8,650 cards sold for over $6.2 Million (Many I do not have prices for).

[DragonWagon]

Mislabeled 1986 Bo Jackson #50T Topps Traded Tiffany PSA 8 cert# 93713031 is NOT a Tiffany card

[DragonWagon]

Mislabeled 1986 Barry Bonds #11T Topps Traded Tiffany PSA 8 cert# 64050259 is NOT a Tiffany card


If they can't get the Bonds right, then what are the chances they got the Griffey Tiffany card before correct?

With no visual difference between a 1989 Traded Tiffany and a base Traded I doubt the grader got it right. IMO, this has to be the most unknown mislabeled card out there.

1989 Ken Griffey Jr #41T Topps Traded Tiffany PSA 8 cert# 64050258 is most likely NOT Tiffany

[superdan49]

Mislabeled PSA 8 1994 Bowman's Best Derek Jeter card. This is not a Refractor, although was recently sold as such by eBay seller adhan2133 for $103.50, which is nearly $100 more than it is worth. PSA cert #94493116. For some reason this '94 Bowman's Best card gives PSA trouble, as it is the second mislabeled Jeter example I've posted in this thread.

[DragonWagon]

Mislabeled 1987 Greg Maddux 70T Topps Traded Tiffany PSA 7 cert# 99282890 is NOT a Tiffany card

[DragonWagon]

Mislabeled 1990 Ken Griffey Jr #336 Topps Tiffany PSA 6 cert# 60723985 is NOT a Tiffany card

[DragonWagon]

Mislabeled 1984 Darryl Strawberry #182 Topps Tiffany PSA 4 cert# 76613279 is NOT Tiffany

[NYBBFAN]

This 2001 Donruss Classics Timeless Tributes numbered 9/100 currently listed on Veriswap and slabbed by BGS has a fake serial number stamp.

BGS cert number: 0001573024