aaron judge sell buy or hold

[NorCalSCM]

Thats me! Camon Red INK..Camon Red INK

[oaklandasfan]

Thank god i did not get kris bryant🤣🤣

[JMoney1985]

I think I'm going to start buying low

[blackbears86]

Originally Posted by imbluestreak23

It’s over

It's not over, but it's not good either.


ESPN saying he will likely be out an extended period of time.

[doowopbruce]

You could always list some at prices you're comfortable with.

[ToppsNowFan]

Lets see those Fire Sales... Who is looking for those pennies on the dollar... Let me know! Guy it TOTALLY injury prone and washed up... SELL SELL SELL... and for CHEAP!!!

[tconte]

Originally Posted by kyle1707

He’s 27 this week

Has 300 hits and 88 hrs

Odds of him ending up with anything close to hof numbers is slim

On the other side he is so popular and a yankee

If healthy he could win mvp or hit 50 hrs any of next 5 years

Imo

I would not touch these 1000-5000 dollar cards of his

If you can still get these numbers I would sell

This post is spot on. In the offseason I remember thinking that Ozzie Albies
needed to get 10 hits a year for four years or something like that to tie
Judge. That was all I needed to know about staying clear of Judge
card wise on anything big money.

Right now the best thing to do is hold or list at your prices and maybe
some things sell.

[rainmaker]

judge is one of the most likable athletes in all of sports. as such his cards will always have some demand. when he is on the field and the yankees are winning his cards will rise in value. buy/hold/sell? the time to sell was asb 2017.

anyone holding or buying in 2018 or 2019 should have understood it was for collecting not roi.

i believe buying the heritage action on a dip for a pc pickup makes a lot of sense. might even be able to flip it with a strong postseason or next spring. buying one of the hundreds of auto cards right now is a waste of time and $.

[waytoomanycards]

Keep buying. Just be selective always buy below whatever the current market is.

Regarding 2017, there were points during that year where prices on many of his cards were well below what they were before this latest injury. Five minutes on pwcc's site can confirm that.

If you're actively buying and selling, the only players you stop buying altogether are the prospects who never make the majors. Otherwise, just look for deals. If you're not buying/selling and are just putting them away for a real long time, then it's probably tough to see a good return no matter what you do.

It's always easier to find deals well below the current market when a player is cold or hurt. When he's hot, they're usually clustered pretty tight. At least, that's been my experience.

[psd2k10]

Originally Posted by Bigbluesooner

Sell. Sell. Sell. Its over. Better get em on Ebay early and CHEAP to at least salvage what you can of your investment.

Sounds like someone wants to buy your stash at a discount! Dont sell. Be patient!

[oaklandasfan]

Originally Posted by psd2k10

Sounds like someone wants to buy your stash at a discount! Dont sell. Be patient!

No kidding the sharks are all around 👻👻

[Giants1964]

Originally Posted by DaaaaBears

Wow, somebody with brains up in here! Anybody who sells Judge now will regret it for sure and it's not even a question that should enter your mind

My original quote..."I am in the hold category. love em or hate em...yankees hold there value. He is a huge guy and has...yes the potential to even be a legit to the 61 hr mark. A definite hold for me!"

Wow was I a seer back then ha ha Wish it were on my other buy and holds!

[imbluestreak23]

Is it too late to buy Bird or did I miss out

[Stifle]

Depends on how he does in playoffs and a roll of the dice if he stays with NY. Its a tough call now that the Yankees let Judge bet on himself and the Yankees’ front office lost.

[JWBlue]

I would sell now.

Yankees chances of advancing in the playoffs are not good. Players that sign a big contract usually do not perform well their 1st season.

[Stifle]

Originally Posted by rainmaker

judge is one of the most likable athletes in all of sports. as such his cards will always have some demand. when he is on the field and the yankees are winning his cards will rise in value. buy/hold/sell? the time to sell was asb 2017.

anyone holding or buying in 2018 or 2019 should have understood it was for collecting not roi.

i believe buying the heritage action on a dip for a pc pickup makes a lot of sense. might even be able to flip it with a strong postseason or next spring. buying one of the hundreds of auto cards right now is a waste of time and $.

Judge seems like a person you would want a daughter to bring home and say here he is. You want him to succeed, and he has!

The days of having contracts averaging 11.5 million for a Miggy from 2003-2015 (13 years) and Pujols from 2001-2011 (12 years) are Done. Those were the big stat years.

[cardsin47]

Sell now - he’s not likely to be an all-time great, but is having what is likely to be his highest profile career year

[majestik101]

Buy and stash

[ThoseBackPages]

BUY!!!!!!!!

[marl1220]

Originally Posted by JWBlue

I would sell now.

Yankees chances of advancing in the playoffs are not good. Players that sign a big contract usually do not perform well their 1st season.

Now, as in this minute? Or now, as in when he wins the MVP or breaks, possibly, the record? the answer could make a considerable $$$$$ difference.

[Americards]

Both, buy and sell

[imbluestreak23]

I bought an A Judge Auto today.

Hope to buy another tomorrow

[marl1220]

wrong thread.