Paul Skenes’ Debut Patch Auto has been pulled

[hermanotarjeta]

When the 2018 bowman ohtani superfractor auto was pulled, I believe Beckett had a full article on the location of the pull. That’s the standard for reporting.

[Poorboy]

So fanatics paid psa to grade plus a portion of perceived value of card ?
To be transparent asked same fee question I’m sgc thread ….
If that’s how that works ?

[aggie4ever]

Originally Posted by hermanotarjeta

The kid in the letter implied his parents found it at a shop for $350.

It actually doesn't. He said his normal LCS raised their price to $350, which was too expensive, so his parents didn't buy it. Then he says they searched for a better price, and found one for $320. So that could be a random ebay seller, or random online seller, or a random LCS he doesn't frequent. So either he doesn't know the name of the LCS, or it wasn't important since it wasn't his normal LCS.

But since BO likes conspiracies, how about this: The LCS isn't direct with Fanatics or an authorized breaker, so Fanatics didn't want them to be named. Since it seems clear the kid was told what types of information to include in his write-up.

[ThoseBackPages]

Originally Posted by Poorboy

Just one question ?
After this is all over ….
How will the event be remembered ?
Fanaticsgate ? Skenesgate ? Lol
Just curious.

Patch Boy

[MiamiMarlinsFan]

Originally Posted by aggie4ever

It actually doesn't. He said his normal LCS raised their price to $350, which was too expensive, so his parents didn't buy it. Then he says they searched for a better price, and found one for $320. So that could be a random ebay seller, or random online seller, or a random LCS he doesn't frequent. So either he doesn't know the name of the LCS, or it wasn't important since it wasn't his normal LCS.

But since BO likes conspiracies, how about this: The LCS isn't direct with Fanatics or an authorized breaker, so Fanatics didn't want them to be named. Since it seems clear the kid was told what types of information to include in his write-up.

We’re analyzing this kid’s letter like it’s the Zapruder film. Let’s go!

[hermanotarjeta]

Originally Posted by aggie4ever

It actually doesn't. He said his normal LCS raised their price to $350, which was too expensive, so his parents didn't buy it. Then he says they searched for a better price, and found one for $320. So that could be a random ebay seller, or random online seller, or a random LCS he doesn't frequent. So either he doesn't know the name of the LCS, or it wasn't important since it wasn't his normal LCS.

But since BO likes conspiracies, how about this: The LCS isn't direct with Fanatics or an authorized breaker, so Fanatics didn't want them to be named. Since it seems clear the kid was told what types of information to include in his write-up.

The kid might not know where they got the box from, but surely the parents who made the purchase do.

Why hasn’t it been revealed yet?

Even “off eBay from dealer x” would have been suitable.

Their publicity releases have been as incompetent as some yahoo articles referencing a photograph but not actually showing the photograph itself in the article, ie clickbait.

Most people here are critical of fanatics because that’s all they want from this story - clickbait.

Zero reporting integrity.

[TimBuckTwo]

Originally Posted by Poorboy

Just one question ?
After this is all over ….
How will the event be remembered ?
Fanaticsgate ? Skenesgate ? Lol
Just curious.

Fanfanfakup

TripleFU if you like

[whitmm]

The letter never implies there was a physical store involved. It starts with mom saying she would get it but work got too busy and she forgot. And then Black Friday came and the price never dropped. But then one day she found a box while for cheaper.

I don't read that and think mom was running all over LA checking all the shops. That reads like they were looking online.

[ThoseBackPages]

the letter is AI

[hermanotarjeta]

Originally Posted by whitmm

The letter never implies there was a physical store involved. It starts with mom saying she would get it but work got too busy and she forgot. And then Black Friday came and the price never dropped. But then one day she found a box while for cheaper.

I don't read that and think mom was running all over LA checking all the shops. That reads like they were looking online.

They could have mentioned the “parents found a box online” but they didn’t.

They are hiding something.

[boxbuster7]

Maybe Fanatics backdoored the card to Paul for a chance to sit in Livvys suite

[hermanotarjeta]

When a person hits a progressive jackpot of $3 million at a casino but wants to remain anonymous, the name of the casino is always, always, always named in all public reports.

Why wasn’t the source released here?

They are hiding something.

[hermanotarjeta]

Originally Posted by boxbuster7

Maybe Fanatics backdoored the card to Paul for a chance to sit in Livvys suite

Like they backdoored the LeBron/curry/durant auto to giannis?

All the fanatics topps now sheep still defending them like they actually had a chance, lol.

[whitmm]

Originally Posted by hermanotarjeta

They could have mentioned the “parents found a box online” but they didn’t.

They are hiding something.

At this point it really doesn't matter for the BOCT. Them saying where the box was purchased isn't going to satisfy anyone. It will just spark more conspiracies.

[hermanotarjeta]

Originally Posted by whitmm

At this point it really doesn't matter for the BOCT. Then saying where the box was purchased isn't going to satisfy anyone. It will just spark more conspiracies.

I think if they simply mentioned they bought a single box from online retailer blowout cards, folks would be satisfied.

[whitmm]

Originally Posted by hermanotarjeta

I think if they simply mentioned they bought a single box from online retailer blowout cards, folks would be satisfied.

No, they wouldn't, and you know it.

But, if they did say it came from BO, would your whole belief system come crumbling down?

[hermanotarjeta]

Originally Posted by whitmm

No, they wouldn't, and you know it.

But, if they did say it came from BO, would your whole belief system come crumbling down?

Please, tell me what my belief system is.

I believe news should be reported properly. It wasn’t done so here, and they are inviting skeptics by doing so.

[whitmm]

Originally Posted by hermanotarjeta

Please, tell me what my belief system is.

You literally just called everyone sheep who thought they had a crack at this card. If it came from a box purchased from BO, then yes, people had a crack at it.

The only way people never had a crack at the card is if it was backdoored.

[hermanotarjeta]

Originally Posted by whitmm

You literally just called everyone sheep who thought they had a crack at this card. If it came from a box purchased from BO, then yes, people had a crack at it.

The only way people never had a crack at the card is if it was backdoored.

Not this card, the topps now triple bk auto.

I still believe in physical pack randomization, not online lotteries.

[bub838]

Originally Posted by hermanotarjeta

When a person hits a progressive jackpot of $3 million at a casino but wants to remain anonymous, the name of the casino is always, always, always named in all public reports.

Why wasn’t the source released here?

They are hiding something.

In some states you can't even claim large lottery jackpots anonymously. Precisely to avoid any signs of impropriety. Gambling is usually under some sort of governing body. But, baseball card gambling is not.

[Osfan81]

My big takeaway in all of this is: people don’t trust Fanatics/Topps. They’re not transparent in much. They overcharge, and everybody that bought a $800 jumbo box and got $30 worth of cards is upset that they didn’t pull it. No matter who pulled it, they’d be upset about it. What this really speaks about is: the need for the 4 letter word: “regulation.” Accountability and transparency are needed especially with Topps having a monopoly next year on almost everything card related. If Topps doesn’t want to do it voluntarily, then they’ll get what they deserve with over regulation.

[BdotHobbs]

Every single thing about this entire situation is completely insane ��

The most insane thing is how concerned people are about knowing the identity of a middle school aged kid

[hermanotarjeta]

Originally Posted by BdotHobbs

Every single thing about this entire situation is completely insane ��

The most insane thing is how concerned people are about knowing the identity of a middle school aged kid

Nobody wants to know the kid’s identity - it’s irrelevant.

Journalistic integrity demands the full story. Where did the box come from is one of the most basic things for the public to know to maintain trust for the company. Their leaving out such an important fact smells of a cover up.

[whitmm]

Originally Posted by hermanotarjeta

Nobody wants to know the kid’s identity - it’s irrelevant.

Journalistic integrity demands the full story. Where did the box come from is one of the most basic things for the public to know to maintain trust for the company. Their leaving out such an important fact smells of a cover up.

Do you read the thread? People absolutely wanted to know the kid's identity. They wanted to know who the dad was. Because they want to know if it was some breaker or a Fanatics employee.

I was looking at the box break section. I see some people don't mention where they purchased the box from. Kept this same energy and go start accusing them of hiding something.

[seanbros55]

Originally Posted by Osfan81

My big takeaway in all of this is: people don’t trust Fanatics/Topps. They’re not transparent in much. They overcharge, and everybody that bought a $800 jumbo box and got $30 worth of cards is upset that they didn’t pull it. No matter who pulled it, they’d be upset about it. What this really speaks about is: the need for the 4 letter word: “regulation.” Accountability and transparency are needed especially with Topps having a monopoly next year on almost everything card related. If Topps doesn’t want to do it voluntarily, then they’ll get what they deserve with over regulation.

In the 3 years since they purchased Topps, they have done absolutely nothing to earn that trust or even the benefit of a doubt in “questionable” events such as this one. In fact, every subsequent mishap/scandal/egregious error they have created further diminishes any good faith.

I expected the worst when they announced the Topps acquisition in January of 2022 and its even worse than I anticipated.