PSA Value vs CGC Value

[mfw13]

Originally Posted by atk825

It's really quite amazing just how undervalued PSA 9s are.

That's because nobody cares about PSA 9's, especially for modern cards where 90% of cards are PSA 9 or better right out of the pack.

I'd rather have a raw card than a PSA 9, and I certainly wouldn't pay any premium for a PSA 9 over raw.

Likewise, if there is a card I need for a auto/insert set in PSA 9, I'll buy it and crack it out, since I store all my cards in binders.

[ThoseBackPages]

Originally Posted by mfw13

That's because nobody cares about PSA 9's, especially for modern cards where 90% of cards are PSA 9 or better right out of the pack.

I'd rather have a raw card than a PSA 9, and I certainly wouldn't pay any premium for a PSA 9 over raw.

Likewise, if there is a card I need for a auto/insert set in PSA 9, I'll buy it and crack it out, since I store all my cards in binders.

hahaha

[MiamiMarlinsFan]

Originally Posted by amolina

I just submitted a PSA 10 that I took out of the case, and sent it to CGC Signature Series. I hope Thosebackpages is correct in their assessment and I get back a CGC 10 Pristine grade. Fingers crossed!

Never assumed a Pristine grade… but good luck.

[OhioLawyerF5]

Originally Posted by mfw13

That's because nobody cares about PSA 9's, especially for modern cards where 90% of cards are PSA 9 or better right out of the pack.



I'd rather have a raw card than a PSA 9, and I certainly wouldn't pay any premium for a PSA 9 over raw.



Likewise, if there is a card I need for a auto/insert set in PSA 9, I'll buy it and crack it out, since I store all my cards in binders.

That's certainly an opinion.

[Rbradleigh]

Originally Posted by atk825

I think this is right. There's certainly a lot of pretty gem minit looking cards sitting in PSA 9 slabs.

You don’t say
Good luck finding the flaw without a loupe and even then? A resurgence and I’ll submit for a review, scared to crack. And no, the lil black mark on the border near the bat is not on the card.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk