WAR: Bonds Ruth Mays Aaron Mantle Williams

[RiceBondsMT2Yng]

BONDS
1986 N/R 3.5 (Gwynn 6.7)
1987 9th 5.8 (Gwynn 8.6)
1988 7th 6.3 (Larkin 7.0)
1989 3rd 8.0 (L. Smith 8.8)
1990 1st 9.7
1991 1st 8.0
1992 1st 9.0
1993 1st 9.9
1994 2nd 6.2 (Bagwell 8.2)
1995 1st 7.5
1996 1st 9.7
1997 4th 8.2 (Walker 9.8)
1998 1st 8.1
1999 N/R 3.8 (Bagwell 7.4)
2000 3rd 7.7 (Helton 8.9)
2001 1st 11.9
2002 1st 11.7
2003 1st 9.2
2004 1st 10.6
2005 N/R 0.6 (Pujols 8.4)
2006 N/R 4.0 (Pujols 8.5)
2007 N/R 3.4 (Pujols 8.7)

RUTH
1914 N/R 0.0 (Speaker 10.0) - Primarily a pitcher
1915 N/R 1.7 (Cobb 9.5) - Primarily a pitcher
1916 N/R 1.6 (Speaker 8.7) - Primarily a pitcher
1917 N/R 2.1 (Cobb 11.3) - Primarily a pitcher
1918 7th 4.7 (Sisler 6.8)
1919 1st 9.1
1920 1st 11.9
1921 1st 12.9
1922 5th 6.4 (Sisler 8.7)
1923 1st 14.2
1924 1st 11.8
1925 N/R 3.5 (Heilmann 7.0)
1926 1st 11.6
1927 1st 12.6
1928 1st 10.2
1929 1st 8.1
1930 1st 10.3
1931 1st 10.5
1932 2nd 8.5 (Foxx 10.4)
1933 5th 6.3 (Foxx 9.0)
1934 9th 5.0 (Gehrig 10.1)
1935 N/R 0.1 (Vaughan 7.3)

MAYS
1951 N/R 3.9 (Robinson 9.7)
1952 N/R 1.3 (Robinson 8.4)
1953 DNP 0.0 (Snider 9.1)
1954 1st 10.5
1955 1st 9.1
1956 1st 7.6 (tie Snider)
1957 1st 8.3
1958 1st 10.2
1959 4th 7.8 (Banks 10.2)
1960 1st 9.5
1961 2nd 8.2 (Aaron 9.5)
1962 1st 10.5
1963 1st 10.6
1964 1st 11.0
1965 1st 11.2
1966 1st 9.0
1967 N/R 4.4 (Santo 9.8)
1968 6th 6.3 (Clemente 8.2)
1969 N/R 3.1 (Aaron/McCovey 8.1)
1970 N/R 5.2 (Bench 7.4)
1971 5th 6.3 (Stargell 7.9)
1972 N/R 1.8 (Morgan 9.3)
1973 N/R 0.0 (Morgan 9.3)

AARON
1954 N/R 1.4 (Mays 10.5)
1955 6th 6.2 (Mays 9.1)
1956 3rd 7.2 (Mays/Snider 7.6)
1957 2nd 8.0 (Mays 8.3)
1958 3rd 7.3 (Mays 10.2)
1959 2nd 8.6 (Banks 10.2)
1960 2nd 8.0 (Mays 9.5)
1961 1st 9.5
1962 3rd 8.5 (Mays 10.5)
1963 2nd 9.1 (Mays 10.6)
1964 7th 6.8 (Mays 11.0)
1965 2nd 7.9 (Mays 11.2)
1966 4th 7.8 (Mays 9.0)
1967 3rd 8.5 (Santo 9.8)
1968 3rd 6.8 (Clemente 8.2)
1969 1st 8.1 (tie McCovey)
1970 N/R 5.0 (Bench 7.4)
1971 3rd 7.2 (Stargell 7.9)
1972 N/R 3.9 (Morgan 9.3)
1973 N/R 4.7 (Morgan 9.3)
1974 N/R 2.1 (Schmidt 9.8)
1975 N/R 0.1 (Morgan 11.0)
1976 N/R 0.4 (Morgan 9.6)

MANTLE
1951 N/R 1.5
1952 2nd 6.4 (Doby 7.0)
1953 3rd 5.8 (Rosen 10.1)
1954 4th 6.9 (Minoso 8.2)
1955 1st 9.5
1956 1st 11.2
1957 1st 11.3
1958 1st 8.7
1959 1st 6.6
1960 2nd 6.4 (Maris 7.5)
1961 1st 10.4
1962 2nd 6.0 (Robinson 6.1)
1963 N/R 2.9 (Allison 7.4)
1964 N/R 4.8 (Robinson 8.1)
1965 N/R 1.8 (Versalles 7.2)
1966 N/R 3.6 (Robinson 7.7)
1967 N/R 3.9 (Yastrzemski 12.4)
1968 N/R 2.7 (Yastrzemski 10.5)

WILLIAMS
1939 4th 6.6 (DiMaggio 8.3)
1940 3rd 6.6 (DiMaggio 7.2)
1941 1st 10.4
1942 1st 10.5
1943 DNP (Boudreau, 8.1)
1944 DNP (Stirnweiss 8.7)
1945 DNP (Stirnweiss 8.8)
1946 1st 10.7
1947 1st 9.6
1948 2nd 8.3 (Boudreau, 10.4)
1949 1st 9.0
1950 N/R 3.9 (Rizzuto 6.8)
1951 1st 7.2
1952 N/R 0.3 (Doby 7.0)
1953 N/R 2.0 (Rosen 10.1)
1954 2nd 7.5 (Minoso, 8.2)
1955 3rd 6.9 (Mantle 9.5)
1956 5th 6.1 (Mantle 11.2)
1957 2nd 9.7 (Mantle 11.3)
1958 N/R 4.0 (Mantle 8.7)
1959 N/R -0.2 (Mantle 6.6)
1960 N/R 3.1 (Maris 7.5)
--

Ladies and gentleman, arguably the three best players of all time, from their initial 1st place finish up to their last top 10 finish...

Bonds
1st - 11
2nd - 1
3rd - 2
4th - 1
N/R - 1

Ruth
1st - 11
2nd - 1
5th - 2
9th - 1
N/R - 1

Mays
1st - 11
2nd - 1
4th - 1
5th - 1
6th - 1
N/R - 3

Doesn't really look like anyone else comes close.