Topps 582 Montgomery Club

[Fanatics2026]

Originally Posted by BRob1

same. mine works fine, I bought a new 582 membership with one of them.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I’m not sure why people in here was saying you couldn’t get a membership with your old account??? I asked that question weeks ago with someone from Topps/fanatics and was told you could it would just be under a new membership, so you have to pay 199 instead of 149

[CapeTownCards]

Originally Posted by Fanatics2026

I’m not sure why people in here was saying you couldn’t get a membership with your old account??? I asked that question weeks ago with someone from Topps/fanatics and was told you could it would just be under a new membership, so you have to pay 199 instead of 149

Agreed, I got to renew all my memberships. They all ship to the same address. I don’t understand Topps’ methods of cutting out some big spenders but leaving smaller accounts. I spent a few thousand during the last membership period, nothing near as much as others mentioned here. I was also one of the recipients of a load of free Finest Flashbacks boxes and an extra SW Sapphire box earlier in the year. So it would make more sense to axe my accounts.
Who knows, no rhyme or reason.
Happy to still be a part of the club. I wasn’t sure if I wanted to renew, but I have a good feeling about the coming year… if not, it’s the cost of a few of those FF boxes.

[BRob1]

Originally Posted by Fanatics2026

I’m not sure why people in here was saying you couldn’t get a membership with your old account??? I asked that question weeks ago with someone from Topps/fanatics and was told you could it would just be under a new membership, so you have to pay 199 instead of 149

the verbiage in the email when they told us we couldn’t renew was definitely vague where it said anyone attempting to purchase a new membership could face additional consequences.

It would not let me renew, but would let me add to cart and buy new, so I gave them the benefit of the doubt that it was intentional. We’ll see if it sticks.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[BRob1]

Originally Posted by CapeTownCards

Agreed, I got to renew all my memberships. They all ship to the same address. I don’t understand Topps’ methods of cutting out some big spenders but leaving smaller accounts. I spent a few thousand during the last membership period, nothing near as much as others mentioned here. I was also one of the recipients of a load of free Finest Flashbacks boxes and an extra SW Sapphire box earlier in the year. So it would make more sense to axe my accounts.
Who knows, no rhyme or reason.
Happy to still be a part of the club. I wasn’t sure if I wanted to renew, but I have a good feeling about the coming year… if not, it’s the cost of a few of those FF boxes.

i would think about changing up the addresses on those accounts. I’d bet at some point in the next year they’ll figure out you have multiple accounts at the same address.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Pacmeyer]

Originally Posted by CapeTownCards

Agreed, I got to renew all my memberships. They all ship to the same address. I don’t understand Topps’ methods of cutting out some big spenders but leaving smaller accounts. I spent a few thousand during the last membership period, nothing near as much as others mentioned here. I was also one of the recipients of a load of free Finest Flashbacks boxes and an extra SW Sapphire box earlier in the year. So it would make more sense to axe my accounts.
Who knows, no rhyme or reason.
Happy to still be a part of the club. I wasn’t sure if I wanted to renew, but I have a good feeling about the coming year… if not, it’s the cost of a few of those FF boxes.

Why would Topps axe your accounts for the FF screwup? They probably aren't aware of it and even if they are, it's a separate matter.

Originally Posted by BRob1

i would think about changing up the addresses on those accounts. I’d bet at some point in the next year they’ll figure out you have multiple accounts at the same address.

Not just addresses but also phone numbers, cc, and email. That's assuming Topps employees at least know how to search a database.

[BRob1]

Originally Posted by Pacmeyer

Why would Topps axe your accounts for the FF screwup? They probably aren't aware of it and even if they are, it's a separate matter.



Not just addresses but also phone numbers, cc, and email. That's assuming Topps employees at least know how to search a database.

true on the other data points as well.

I don’t think they are one for one comparing who beat them on ff, but I do think it was a big impetus for cracking down on multiple accounts. Assume in the aftermath they realized there were individuals who got close to 100 free boxes which probably highlighted to them just how widespread multi accounting was.

The irony is now they catch the guys with 3-4 accounts but the more sophisticated guys are still getting as many orders through as they want, like on brooklyn collection.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ctcardexchange]

I can't wait for the notice of a class action suit

[Fanatics2026]

I do feel bad for people who thought they couldn’t open a new membership with their old account. People were referencing possible consequences from topps and it scared them lol

[THammers]

Originally Posted by Fanatics2026

I do feel bad for people who thought they couldn’t open a new membership with their old account. People were referencing possible consequences from topps and it scared them lol

There's still plenty of time for consequences. Wouldn't surprise me if Topps takes their money and then cancels their membership later. It seems arrogant to assume they could create a new membership despite the e-mail clearly saying they couldn't. We've seen Topps screw people over left and right even though CS either told them to do something or said it was ok when it wasn't.

[Mandy1320]

Notables from 2 boxes. Plus base of Julio and Pena

[Archimedes]

Originally Posted by Fanatics2026

I’m not sure why people in here was saying you couldn’t get a membership with your old account??? I asked that question weeks ago with someone from Topps/fanatics and was told you could it would just be under a new membership, so you have to pay 199 instead of 149

I thought the email from Topps was clear but decided to play dumb and asked anyway. This is what they said: "You are not able to renew or purchase a new membership to the Montgomery Club."

[Fanatics2026]

Originally Posted by THammers

There's still plenty of time for consequences. Wouldn't surprise me if Topps takes their money and then cancels their membership later. It seems arrogant to assume they could create a new membership despite the e-mail clearly saying they couldn't. We've seen Topps screw people over left and right even though CS either told them to do something or said it was ok when it wasn't.

It’s not something I have to worry about since I did not try and get a new membership, but people that tried so far so good...

[rippev]

Originally Posted by Mandy1320

Notables from 2 boxes. Plus base of Julio and Pena

The border of that Tucker looks great with the Astros. Great looking cards as per usual!

[BRob1]

Originally Posted by Archimedes

I thought the email from Topps was clear but decided to play dumb and asked anyway. This is what they said: "You are not able to renew or purchase a new membership to the Montgomery Club."

that’s not exactly what my email said. it said I couldn’t renew, then was sort of vague about could I buy a new one or not. “may” result in additional consequences. I completely understand them not wanting me to have multiple memberships. seems pretty punitive if I couldn’t even have one at new member price.


NOTICE: You are ineligible to renew your 582 Montgomery Club membership in 2023
 
 Dear 2022 582 Montgomery Club Member,

Following thorough review of our terms & conditions, our 582 Montgomery Club team has deemed your account ineligible for renewal for the upcoming 2023 membership year. We have found multiple memberships associated with your household, thereby violating the one (1) membership per household rule as laid out in the program’s terms & conditions.

We will be monitoring all members to ensure that they are acting in accordance with the terms & conditions. Any attempt to purchase a new membership slot may result in additional consequences.

You may access the full terms & conditions of the program on the 582 Montgomery Club webpage here.

Sincerely,
Topps 582 Montgomery Club Team


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Fanatics2026]

Originally Posted by BRob1

that’s not exactly what my email said. it said I couldn’t renew, then was sort of vague about could I buy a new one or not. “may” result in additional consequences.


NOTICE: You are ineligible to renew your 582 Montgomery Club membership in 2023
 
 Dear 2022 582 Montgomery Club Member,

Following thorough review of our terms & conditions, our 582 Montgomery Club team has deemed your account ineligible for renewal for the upcoming 2023 membership year. We have found multiple memberships associated with your household, thereby violating the one (1) membership per household rule as laid out in the program’s terms & conditions.

We will be monitoring all members to ensure that they are acting in accordance with the terms & conditions. Any attempt to purchase a new membership slot may result in additional consequences.

You may access the full terms & conditions of the program on the 582 Montgomery Club webpage here.

Sincerely,
Topps 582 Montgomery Club Team


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Did you get charged already??

[BRob1]

Originally Posted by Fanatics2026

Did you get charged already??

good question. i just checked and yes I have been charged. l

I will add, i’m not sure that means anything given how long it’s taken them to issue refunds on other products.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Archimedes]

Originally Posted by BRob1

good question. i just checked and yes I have been charged. l

I will add, i’m not sure that means anything given how long it’s taken them to issue refunds on other products.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yeah, generally speaking, Topps is happy to take a free loan.

[Campbelljh3]

Do we get tracking for our factory set 3 pack? I still haven’t seen anything on this

[Fanatics2026]

Originally Posted by Campbelljh3

Do we get tracking for our factory set 3 pack? I still haven’t seen anything on this

All pending here too

[RobDerhak]

Cards designs are beautiful...one of my 4 boxes had an extra auto...3 HOF autos in 4 boxes...and I still feel like this is my worst Brooklyn break ever

Back to back years hitting a Walker Buehler purple auto /10. Everything I hit is FT, looking for Witt Jr

Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk

[MichaelDang]

my 4 came today, definitely so much value compared to any product in terms of $$$ per quality auto, wish i got more

autos
jeremy pena blue /30
ozzie smith blue /30
cc sabathia yellow /50
ke'bryan hayes yellow /50
don mattingly black /75
pete alonso /75
wade boggs /99
heliot ramos /99

other stuff:
mike trout terminal /36
cal ripken purple /15
vlad jr orange /25
nick allen blue /40
david ortiz gold /50
bob gibson black /75
royce lewis /99
mackenzie gore /99
christy mathewson /99
wander and witt base

[SaltyCracker]

Best card from 4 boxes. Ended up with 10 autos.

[prodigylush]

Originally Posted by RobDerhak

Cards designs are beautiful...one of my 4 boxes had an extra auto...3 HOF autos in 4 boxes...and I still feel like this is my worst Brooklyn break ever

Back to back years hitting a Walker Buehler purple auto /10. Everything I hit is FT, looking for Witt Jr

Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk

Would take a price on Sandberg blue auto.

[Mandy1320]

See, I dont get it. How does Topps price a product that has at least 2 on-card autos (packed with HoF) for almost half of a dud like TCS? Do they draw the prices out of a hat?

[derrickwhenry74]

Got around to opening my MC Ginter X box. 1 auto box (not noteworthy), but I did get a numbered mini…



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk