Ohtani ain't carrying crap.

[spuds1961]

Originally Posted by ninjacookies

Based on your OP and other replies ITT it sounds like the entire premise of this thread was based off of 'profit.'

And it certainly was not a knock on the manufacturers, it was solely a smear campaign by you to try and imply Ohtani himself was a 'bust' and fraud after a whole few weeks of ST ball.

But of course, you did not do a thing to mask your motives from the slew of praises in the Judge megathread...so you had to make it clear Judge was the benchmark, even though he is pretty much the epitome of a hot and cold streak hitter.

Might as well just say Trout is the best ROI bargain in the history of the game and people were foolish for investing in any other prospect since 2011. Since we all have the privilege of hindsight vision...

If Judge slumps, it's probably:

>he's a damn rookie, have patience
>b-b-b-ut...his shoulder
>slumps are a part of the ups and downs of baseball

I'm not sure if any of this is resonating, but it'd probably be best to refrain from making these kinds of posts again if you don't want to subject yourself to the ridicule.

And the Ohtani warriors remark was a weak defense mechanism. You think the people pointing out your flawed logic are all Shohei superfans, including the resident mod Houdini? Makes sense.

Ironic thing is, I don't see too many Ohtani fans creating new off color remarks about Judge just to raise Ohtani stock....

You could have made this thread '_playerx__ ain't crap' after exhibition ball and still would have looked just as foolish. It's best not to dig yourself a deeper hole with more replies, man.

Obviously you are the one obsessed with trying to read into me. I had my reasons for saying what I said and even offered you an olive branch but here you are still coming after me. I see you find it easy to argue when you think you know everything but seriously you don't know much about me or my reasoning.

[palmetto7]

As I tell everyone....Judge,Harper,Trout,Bryant suck.....sell your cards now....ty

[Chrisyork33]

What if he did carry crap doe?

[spuds1961]

Originally Posted by Chrisyork33

What if he did carry crap doe?

He would be the poster boy for 2018 products and sales which he is fastly becoming.

[Orange October]

Already reminding me of last years Joe Mauer thread

[Boo]

Originally Posted by Chrisyork33

What if he did carry crap doe?

I guess he would stink

[ninjacookies]

Originally Posted by spuds1961

Obviously you are the one obsessed with trying to read into me. I had my reasons for saying what I said and even offered you an olive branch but here you are still coming after me. I see you find it easy to argue when you think you know everything but seriously you don't know much about me or my reasoning.

I made less than a handful of replies pointing out your fallacies, and you continue to deflect.

The olive branch was a cute gesture, but I'm not Tarzan.


I still love you, but you need to stop this type of nonsense.

[hairysasquatch]

Originally Posted by Chrisyork33

What if he did carry crap doe?

I carry crap when I walk my dog.

[texmcpherson]

Thread in result of someone taking Spring Training stats too serious

[spuds1961]

Originally Posted by ninjacookies

I made less than a handful of replies pointing out your fallacies, and you continue to deflect.

The olive branch was a cute gesture, but I'm not Tarzan.


I still love you, but you need to stop this type of nonsense.

Thank you for pointing out my fallacies, but I was wrong about judging him based on spring training but I am also not the only person who ever read a player wrong. I am not deflecting as I am still here, and until this 3 game hot streak nobody seemed that high on Ohtani.

[ThoseBackPages]

i am not a buyer, but he can only do good for the hobby

2018 is already ruined for Heritage and will probably be bad for other products, but unfortunately im not a big fan of non-heritage

[imbluestreak23]

Can't wait to get my Heritage Action back from PSA

[ThoseBackPages]

Originally Posted by imbluestreak23

Can't wait to get my Heritage Action back from PSA

any non Ohtani's sent in?

[Eckstein197]

Originally Posted by spuds1961

I am glad he is doing well, just remember it is a long season with ups and downs, remember how horrible Judge was after the all-star break only to resurface in September to break the rookie home run record.

So we shouldn't jump to conclusions after a small game sample size?

Pot calling the kettle black there.

[Eckstein197]

Originally Posted by Orange October

Already reminding me of last years Joe Mauer thread

That's an absolutely legendary thread. So many years involved in that as well

[imbluestreak23]

Originally Posted by ThoseBackPages

any non Ohtani's sent in?

Oh man, some scrub named Acuna and a #ALLRISE

[ThoseBackPages]

Originally Posted by imbluestreak23

Oh man, some scrub named Acuna and a #ALLRISE

NICE!

let me know if any 9s appear!

[Eckstein197]

Originally Posted by ThoseBackPages

NICE!

let me know if any 9s appear!

Why are you chasing 9s, I hear all the cool kids are chasing 7s nowadays

[TimBuckTwo]

#ALL RISE !!!!!

[ninjacookies]

Originally Posted by spuds1961

Thank you for pointing out my fallacies, but I was wrong about judging him based on spring training but I am also not the only person who ever read a player wrong. I am not deflecting as I am still here, and until this 3 game hot streak nobody seemed that high on Ohtani.

We are all good. It happens.

Just can't understand why we all can't enjoy the crop of new talent in the game and root for their success. It's healthy and makes watching fun.

Hell, I've even had a few good words in the Judge thread (*gasp* amirite?)

[ThoseBackPages]

Originally Posted by Eckstein197

Why are you chasing 9s, I hear all the cool kids are chasing 7s nowadays

hell yea, i'll take any non-10!

[spuds1961]

Originally Posted by ninjacookies

We are all good. It happens.

Just can't understand why we all can't enjoy the crop of new talent in the game and root for their success. It's healthy and makes watching fun.

Hell, I've even had a few good words in the Judge thread (*gasp* amirite?)

Thank you and I am rooting for a lot of the newer crop I have a nice benintendi collection without even trying seems like I pulled him in everything. I am partial to the 2017 class as there were a lot of players carrying that year. I haven't been able to find gypsy queen by me yet but I am sure that is the product I will pull my first Ohtani card from. I hope Ohtani continues to do well but I also want to see some other players from this years class get some love.

[ninjacookies]

Originally Posted by spuds1961

Thank you and I am rooting for a lot of the newer crop I have a nice benintendi collection without even trying seems like I pulled him in everything. I am partial to the 2017 class as there were a lot of players carrying that year. I haven't been able to find gypsy queen by me yet but I am sure that is the product I will pull my first Ohtani card from. I hope Ohtani continues to do well but I also want to see some other players from this years class get some love.

The talent pool is loaded. Same with basketball. It's incredible to witness as a spectator. You even have second tier, lesser hyped guys like Devers and Hoskins with huge upside.

It's a great time to be a fan.

[spuds1961]

Originally Posted by ninjacookies

The talent pool is loaded. Same with basketball. It's incredible to witness as a spectator. You even have second tier, lesser hyped guys like Devers and Hoskins with huge upside.

It's a great time to be a fan.

What's cool is when you go thru older cards you have and find cards of guys you didn't even know had cards for that year, I didn't realize Devers had bowman cards in earlier products and Hoskins was in panini earlier than I thought.

[ziggyz129]

OT is showing us his tits.