Rather have an 8/9 or a 6/10?

[Nomad]

So this thing I found on my feed yesterday and already lost track of posed a pretty interesting question.



For context:

"What happened? Not sure if we missed previous discussions on this but it seems the Jordan Game Jersey Auto that once held the record for the most expensive Jordan card ever sold has been regraded and gone from a Professional Sports Authenticator - PSA 8/9 Auto when it sold at Goldin in May 21 to a PSA 6/10 Auto as per the current PSA imagery.
Does anyone know the story behind this? Did we totally miss something here?"

"Looks like it was reslabbed and parts of the card near the jersey swatch peeled off.. probably got stuck on the PSA case. Ouch."

"This isn't a case of the owner trying to get a better grade. If it was regraded it would have a new cert number.
Owner most likely had the card reholdered and PSA damaged it during the process. Which I'm sure they're insured for that kind of stuff."

"when you submit for reslab, you're forced to sign your rights away. The waiver specifically says they are not liable for any damage. I went through this issue with PSA twice in the last year."

"They retraced the auto after snapping the card. Probably dinged the card during the snapping, lmao. Classic PSA sh-"

So the question is, all things being equal, rather have an 8/9 or a 6/10?