Topps 200% Redemption Replacement

mgsenny · 01-07-2026, 12:20 PM

Saw some chatter about this, figured I'd pop it back up.

For those unaware, Topps now gives us the opportunity to request a replacement of our redemption if it's been over 6 months. They'll determine value and offer 200% of that value. I was given the option of store credit, cards/product, or a combination of both. I opted for cards/product and gave them a list of things I'd be interested in.

Anyway the redemption I had been waiting on for 6+ months was a Randy Orton Topps Chrome Gold Auto /50. I was surprised I could even request a replacement because this card has hit the market so I wonder if he only returned some of his cards.

Topps determined I'd receive $400 in value which I was more than happy with. I told them I was a Yankee fan and grew up on the core 4, also loved Aaron Judge, and that I'm a Maryland Terps fan and was interested in Derik Queen stuff...

Well, I just got the shipping notification and checked my Topps portal. I'm due to receive a 2025 Sterling Awards Auto Relic - Derek Jeter /25. Card isn't in hand yet but I am absolutely thrilled with their selection. So yeah, if you have pending redemptions >6 months that you're willing to forgo, this might be a solid option for you.

01-07-2026, 12:20 PM	#1
mgsenny Member Join Date: Nov 2012 Posts: 1,093 mgsenny25	Topps 200% Redemption Replacement Saw some chatter about this, figured I'd pop it back up. For those unaware, Topps now gives us the opportunity to request a replacement of our redemption if it's been over 6 months. They'll determine value and offer 200% of that value. I was given the option of store credit, cards/product, or a combination of both. I opted for cards/product and gave them a list of things I'd be interested in. Anyway the redemption I had been waiting on for 6+ months was a Randy Orton Topps Chrome Gold Auto /50. I was surprised I could even request a replacement because this card has hit the market so I wonder if he only returned some of his cards. Topps determined I'd receive $400 in value which I was more than happy with. I told them I was a Yankee fan and grew up on the core 4, also loved Aaron Judge, and that I'm a Maryland Terps fan and was interested in Derik Queen stuff... Well, I just got the shipping notification and checked my Topps portal. I'm due to receive a 2025 Sterling Awards Auto Relic - Derek Jeter /25. Card isn't in hand yet but I am absolutely thrilled with their selection. So yeah, if you have pending redemptions >6 months that you're willing to forgo, this might be a solid option for you.