Topps Damage Submission

sandlotsportcards · 04-10-2025, 06:21 AM

I typically don’t submit cards for replacement unless it’s of decent value and replacing makes sense from a selling standpoint. I recently sent in a Tyler Fitzgerald Heritage High Red Ink auto that had a corner that was damaged. Topps received it and updated it very quickly which I was surprised and pleased with. They also ruled within a few hours that it was not being replaced because they didn’t have any replacements. Have they gone away from even replacing items with something else when they don’t have the exact replacement? I sent in an item a year or so ago and they didn’t have any replacements exact replacement but they did send me a couple cards as a replacement. Just wondering if the process has changed or if I should try pushing back to get something.

04-10-2025, 06:21 AM	#1
sandlotsportcards Member Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Massillon Ohio Posts: 3,171 sandlotsportcards nkirkbride	Topps Damage Submission I typically don’t submit cards for replacement unless it’s of decent value and replacing makes sense from a selling standpoint. I recently sent in a Tyler Fitzgerald Heritage High Red Ink auto that had a corner that was damaged. Topps received it and updated it very quickly which I was surprised and pleased with. They also ruled within a few hours that it was not being replaced because they didn’t have any replacements. Have they gone away from even replacing items with something else when they don’t have the exact replacement? I sent in an item a year or so ago and they didn’t have any replacements exact replacement but they did send me a couple cards as a replacement. Just wondering if the process has changed or if I should try pushing back to get something.