What would you do if you received a card with a 1/3 inch scratch?

[taylor5877]

I realize folks like to hammer OP's of stuff like this...but I feel like an indent of that magnitude at least deserves a picture or mention.

If I were the seller and I messed up that bad on a card I advertised as pack fresh and didn't know it was there, I'd refund you and tell you to keep it.

Examples (not all inclusive)
of defects I feel fairly fall under "pack fresh" with no mention:

1. Foreign material in a chrome card surface. Bane of your existence fishing for raw, gradable chrome cards, but a fact of manufacture.
2. Slight wear to corners or borders on paper cards to put it into a gradable 8 range
3. Small breaks in gloss of cards as they came from the factory-panini is good about this one in their cheap paper cards.
4. Some edge chipping on the back of paper stock cards
5. A slightly bad back corner on a chrome card.
6. Surface dimples on chrome cards-try to picture them, but pointing out every one is excessive.
7. Centering...take good pics, but it is what it is