Is it ok to give a sketch artist feedback if something looks off?

[Cavaliercards]

Originally Posted by Faulkenburg

I disagree. This artist did solid work. They put forth significant effort. Granted, the noses are off but that didn't call for public shaming. The noses aren't even"bad", certainly not worth all this. The original question was if it would have been out of line to mention this to the artist privately. The members on this board crossed that line ages ago.

I still say there is nothing wrong with constructive feedback in a private manner.

Now, when it comes to 30 second crap sketches in a $150 box....go at it, but give the publisher just as much (if not more) flack for it.

Again art varies per person, I am not saying effort was not put forth.

I can walk into the National Gallery tomorrow and look at a photograph and say it is hideous and the artist did a poor job, you can be beside me and show me where you think my opinion is wrong. Guess what? We both are right.