This would be pop 1 gem mint? 1/1

[Joshchapo23]

I started the PSA gem 10 pop 1 1/1? Thread
I read the replies so this would actually be 1/1 and pop 1?
Would this be a gem 10 through PSA?

[splitrockgamer]

its a pop 1 1/1 now.. if it gets a psa 8 its a pop 1 1/1

[Joshchapo23]

Ok, so regardless of graded or not in the graded card world a true 1/1 is still only going to be a stamped 1/1?

I'm not debating anyone's answers just trying to get all best answers for my own self from veteran collectors in the graded cards.
Again I am new to graded cards. However I do have gem 10 rookies of mattingly, those were just for myself to have perfect rookies of mattingly. No questions with those.
Example : What if the print run is 10 and all 10 have been graded and only 1 comes out at a gem mint? And rest are 8-9 grades.

[splitrockgamer]

Originally Posted by Joshchapo23

Ok, so regardless of graded or not in the graded card world a true 1/1 is still only going to be a stamped 1/1?

I'm not debating anyone's answers just trying to get all best answers for my own self from veteran collectors in the graded cards.
Again I am new to graded cards. However I do have gem 10 rookies of mattingly, those were just for myself to have perfect rookies of mattingly. No questions with those.
Example : What if the print run is 10 and all 10 have been graded and only 1 comes out at a gem mint? And rest are 8-9 grades.

In your example the gem mint 10 would be a POP 1 .. yes because the population of gem mint 10s of that exact card = 1. It does not make it a 1/1 technically because there is more than 1 printed, so a grade cannot transform a card into a /1 no matter if it is the only 1 to receive that high of a grade. I mean you could argue that what if they were all 8s and 9s of the print run to 10 .. and you got a 5 .. is that a 1/1?

However on the flip side every 1/1 is a POP 1 .. EVERY SINGLE 1/1 that is graded is a POP 1 because it is the only one that was ever made so for that specific card there is a POPulation of 1 and there can only ever be a population of 1.

So all stamped 1/1s are a POP 1, but not all POP 1s are a 1/1 .. in my book.

[LC2nine10]

It's a pop 1
#/10
There's still 10 of then, the grade has nothing to do with the total number of cards

[Joshchapo23]

Awesome I like the info and it is great! Glad I got some info before diving into graded cards.
So what makes a graded card worth so much more then an ungraded card if it's possible the ungraded card could be in better condition? Is it the "professional" grade? (Whether it be bgs,PSA,sgc.)

[13goyankees13]

It's partially because it gives you a better understanding of the condition than scans, partially because it looks better, and partially because it provides better protection than a toploader. Plus it theoretically guarantees that the card isn't fake although I wouldn't trust it much considering how many clearly fake autographs reputable companies have authenticated.

[marinocollector]

I think you should crack it out of the case and resubmit it to BGS so that way it can be a 1/1 POP 2

[hxcmilkshake]

Originally Posted by marinocollector

I think you should crack it out of the case and resubmit it to BGS so that way it can be a 1/1 POP 2

Love this.

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk

[splitrockgamer]

Originally Posted by marinocollector

I think you should crack it out of the case and resubmit it to BGS so that way it can be a 1/1 POP 2

What if it gets a 9?

[glen87]

Originally Posted by splitrockgamer

What if it gets a 9?

wouldn't that then make it the even more rare dual 1/1 pop 1 in both the 9 and 10 category

[TomRacer]

Originally Posted by splitrockgamer

However on the flip side every 1/1 is a POP 1 .. EVERY SINGLE 1/1 that is graded is a POP 1 because it is the only one that was ever made so for that specific card there is a POPulation of 1 and there can only ever be a population of 1.

So all stamped 1/1s are a POP 1, but not all POP 1s are a 1/1 .. in my book.

I didn’t expect these to grade the same but I am glad they did; I now have the very elusive and seldom seen 1/1 Pop 2 that some claim doesn't exist.

[BH34]

Originally Posted by TomRacer

I didn’t expect these to grade the same but I am glad they did; I now have the very elusive and seldom seen 1/1 Pop 2 that some claim doesn't exist.

haha, that's awesome.
I think it was earlier this year, when I saw some 'topps transcendent' 1/1 stamped cards - I know I saw more than one of a few of them, though I'm not sure if it was ever proven to be multiple 1/1s -
though I seem to recall various 1/1s of the same card to be on ebay at the same time by different sellers on at least one occasion..