Quote:
Originally Posted by Dallas Cowboys
You were trying to bait me in saying whether Aikman and Elway were better than Young or Marino. Aikman is in because he has three rings, if he just had one like Stafford he probably doesn’t get in.
When I’m looking at who should get in I’m only comparing who they played against in their era.
2000-2025
Favre and Warner and Peyton Manning are in.
Brady, Brees and Big Ben and Rodgers and Wilson will get in.
Eli will eventually get in.
Mahomes will get in.
That’s who I compare Rivers, Stafford and Ryan to. Compared to those guys above they are not hall of Famers.
I collect Hall of Fame autographs so I know how it works. You think All Pros and all decade don’t matter you are wrong. The guys that vote for those usually also have a hall of fame vote. They look at those accolades.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
|
I can see valid points in favor or against in the thread from a bunch of commentors but are you referring to Russell Wilson here?
Curious on how you have Wilson in the HOF but not Stafford. Not agreeing or disagreeing with either side, just wondering what that comparison looked like.