Quote:
Originally Posted by majestik101
Sherilyn Fenn Twin Peaks Limited Edition autograph from 2018 Rittenhouse Twin Peaks.
One sold for $120 in September with one bid. Doubt very highly that was a legitimate sale though, considering that this card is extremely rare and typically sells for 350-$500.
There's one on eBay priced higher than mine ($600). Seller is in China. So I know my card is in the neighborhood.
Currently I have my BO set at 2/3 my posted price. I am willing to negotiate if it reaches the halfway mark. A $50 offer is just a ridiculous troll-job.
|
I see two sold listings on 130pt from sept for the exact card, one $129.99 and one 130.00 EUR. Could that be around market value? Maybe. But tbh when there are no other active listings on ebay other than the 600 obo, it's kinda a nice position to be in as the seller, and no harm in trying for more.
As a seller myself, when it comes to these offers.....eh I dunno. I'd go out of my way to block if it's absolutely outrageous like $2 on a $500 listing. I just got offers of like $50, $60, and $50 on three items I have listed in the $400-$500 a piece range, which were way lowballs. I just strict declined them..doesnt take any effort at least, but they're not in the counteroffering range. Probably wont block for just that, but if they send more offers like $75 or $90 I might just let the offer sit without response, so then at least there wont be an option to send more offers until they expire, and most buyers just move on then. If a seller wants to block for a $50 offer for a $500 item, in their right of course
I've done the auto-decline option....idk, I think my biggest issue with it is it reveals your cards in the negotiation as a seller- buyers like to fish for that auto-decline amount, and once arrived at it, will think 'hey the seller seems to be ok with that price since it's more than the autodecline', and then feel like they have no reason to pay more than that. I know the seller doesnt
have to be ok with that price still and certainly can hold out for higher...but it still seems like revealing their hand, in the same vein of that oh so common question buyers ask in messages: 'whats the lowest you'll go?'
Plus all the other reasons to not have autodecline mentioned above. That said, if it's like a $3000 item, I may still just go with an autodecline of like $1000 to weed out the troll offers, even though it's
not the lowest I would go (as in I wouldnt go that low).