Quote:
Originally Posted by joeytortellini
Seller had the listing up with the graded card in display, was asking $180 for PSA 5. Would not have paid more than 80 for the raw Mays-agree it's not a 5, I actually think that the Aaron would be EXMT+ if it weren't for the off centering, marks, and print defects(the corners are the sharpest I've ever seen on a raw vintage)
|
That Mays also may get a MC qualifier from the looks of it. The back of the card is cut off where his stats are. The cards both look authentic, but will not grade well with the centering.
I see that you are new to vintage and I think you are using your modern grading criteria for vintage. Sharp corners are nice, but when it comes to vintage, eye-appeal is king. A lot of vintage collectors, including myself, would rather have a lower graded centered card.