Redeem or Sell?
 

Pulled the Seager /5 Silver Signing Gold Ink...saw that he has redemptions in his last Panini Product..the question is do I sell or redeem? =/ Seems like it would be such a gorgeous card..but not worth a Sheffield AU

Anyone have any thoughts?

If its a card you really want I'd redeem it and if you end up not getting the card you wanted or it's not fair value write TOPPS a letter very specifically listing the players/ cards you believe are a fair replacement. If not they'll just give you Joe Schmo

[QUOTE=taylor13905;5227836]If its a card you really want I'd redeem it and if you end up not getting the card you wanted or it's not fair value write TOPPS a letter very specifically listing the players/ cards you believe are a fair replacement. If not they'll just give you Joe Schmo[/QUOTE]

I would like if I got it live..its /5..and I don't want it to get replaced with an /500. It's supposed to be a gorgeous card...grrrrr.

I redeem nothing anymore so I'd sell it. Can't trust Topps to deliver.

[QUOTE=Tugarpj;5228003]I redeem nothing anymore so I'd sell it. Can't trust Topps to deliver.[/QUOTE]

this ^^^^^^^^^^^^^ I can't believe people still want to redeem cards with all the horror stories you read about everyday.

Get your money out of it. Sell it now. The likelihood of it ever getting made right now is roughly 50/50.

Sell, let someone else deal with a terrible replacement.