Return card?
 

I wanted to see what you guys think on this. Should i return this card. The pic on auction was hard to see this print line and the title used the word "mint".
Im a little old school as ive never returned a card before and been purchasing on ebay since 2003. However ive had a few returns on cards ive sold on there for less then this. What do you guys think.
Thanks, Joe
[ATTACH]495550[/ATTACH]

I know print lines can affect a bgs/psa grade but to me print lines aren’t part of the condition

I believe it would still get a mint 9 grade with that line.

It's situations like these why whenever I sold on Ebay I did not list a condition. Even mint is subjective to the viewer.

What did the photo in the listing look like?

[ATTACH]495551[/ATTACH]

Are you talking about the black line behind Murray's right shoulder going down?

If so that's not a print line.

[QUOTE=Ray27Ray52;16647687]Are you talking about the black line behind Murray's right shoulder going down?

If so that's not a print line.[/QUOTE]

no by his elbow

[QUOTE=03cobrakid;16647685][ATTACH]495551[/ATTACH][/QUOTE]

I can see the print line from this picture.

There's also a faint scratch below the RC logo.

wow guys, no card is gonna be perfect. Anyway, if the seller allows a return, why not.

[QUOTE=PokeyAndG;16647824]wow guys, no card is gonna be perfect. Anyway, if the seller allows a return, why not.[/QUOTE]

its crazy how its got. i never would have asked this years ago i had a 3 4 year absences from the hobby now everything I have has to be graded or at least be able to obtain a 9 haha

[QUOTE=03cobrakid;16647861]its crazy how its got. i never would have asked this years ago i had a 3 4 year absences from the hobby now everything I have has to be graded or at least be able to obtain a 9 haha[/QUOTE]

I would highly suggest purchasing graded cards from here on out if you expect a 9 or better on everything.

Return it? [URL="https://www.ebay.com/itm/2019-Panini-Prizm-Disco-301-Kyler-Murray-RC-Rookie-Gem-Mint-PSA-10-/333724227583?hash=item4db38397ff%3Ag%3ATj8AAOSwdAVfYtFg&nma=true&si=AVSqpc2XtEZC1D6UFlHewyzm5Xg%253D&orig_cvip=true&nordt=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557"]This PSA 10[/URL] has the same print line (a little lower on the card).

In fact, it looks like most of these cards have a line.

[QUOTE=jscotta1989;16647870]I would highly suggest purchasing graded cards from here on out if you expect a 9 or better on everything.[/QUOTE]

im talking about when selling cards now

[QUOTE=TheFrenzy;16647893]Return it? [URL="https://www.ebay.com/itm/2019-Panini-Prizm-Disco-301-Kyler-Murray-RC-Rookie-Gem-Mint-PSA-10-/333724227583?hash=item4db38397ff%3Ag%3ATj8AAOSwdAVfYtFg&nma=true&si=AVSqpc2XtEZC1D6UFlHewyzm5Xg%253D&orig_cvip=true&nordt=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557"]This PSA 10[/URL] has the same print line (a little lower on the card).

In fact, it looks like most of these cards have a line.[/QUOTE]

ill check it out thanks for the heads up.

[QUOTE=03cobrakid;16647944]im talking about when selling cards now[/QUOTE]

My apologies, I misunderstood. But I do agree with that when selling. One of the main reasons I’ve gotten into grading over the last couple of years. So so so much easier to sell, and to buy as well really, when dealing with slabs.

OP, I really had to look to figure out what you were referring to. It has great eye appeal.

Think it gets into a bit of sketchy territory returning cards after you receive them because of small imperfections.

Sent from my SM-G986U using Tapatalk

If you expected a PSA 10 card then pony up the money and buy one. This card is mint. This is exactly why I am scared to sell anything now; buyers like you.

[QUOTE=OldReignman;16648405]If you expected a PSA 10 card then pony up the money and buy one. This card is mint. This is exactly why I am scared to sell anything now; buyers like you.[/QUOTE]

At least he had the decency to ask a bunch of strangers on a forum before exploiting the diction of the seller.

[QUOTE=xposipx;16648419]At least he had the decency to ask a bunch of strangers on a forum before exploiting the diction of the seller.[/QUOTE]

I have a feeling he will still return it but hey that’s why I am super careful with the wording I choose when selling. Even though the card is mint exactly like the seller said.

No, I don’t think you should return that, nor should it be allowed.

[QUOTE=Davis;16648443]No, I don’t think you should return that, nor should it be allowed.[/QUOTE]

I agree with you like I said I've made over 600 purchases on ebay and never have made a return. But ppl have returned cards to me for alot less then this card. Just gauging what forum thought im gona hold on to it.
Thanks Joe