Will Aaron Judge Re-sign w/ the Yankees?
 

:coffee:

If the Yanks pony up you moron!

All Judge all the time!!!!! 66 WNNNNNNNNBC!

next, I need a thread on where he ate dinner tonight

Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk

Will Aaron Judge retire?

It's possible.

Positive for nandrolone.

I think we've come to the point where if he thought he'd done something wrong he would have admitted it. His apology did not provide that. You can tell he wanted to skewer the testing system but he probably couldn't for whatever reason.

Did he fart? I gots to know.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[QUOTE=rman112;18436754]It's possible.[/QUOTE]

..<3..

How will history remember Aaron Judge?

Is Aaron Judge overrated?

Is Aaron Judge underrated?

Somebody create MOAR Aaron Judge Threadz

This is lining up for what will be considered an all time worst contract ever. Doesn't matter who signs him. His body will not age well and he will be 31 next season.

I keep telling people he will be going to the Mets [emoji41]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It's such a unique situation. On one hand, he's obviously really good, he's a fan favorite, and he's stated many times how he loves NY and being a Yankee.

On the other hand, he'll be 31 next year and signing older players has bit Cashman one too many times IMO. If the Yankees don't win the WS this year, they will look to get better next year but if all they have space for salary wise is signing Aaron Judge, it won't make the team any better (it will be a lot worse but still). Then there's always the chance that there is a team out there in a better position to sign him than the Yankees and won't let him stay in NY.

If the Yankees win the World Series, then he stays. Hal and Brian will make sure of that based off the jersey sales alone. Hell, I'll buy one.

Judge: please come home to Boston. THANK YOU!

I honestly think he's going to stay a Yankee. Cashman and Judge will meet somewhere in the middle on salary, offer lots of incentives or maybe some deferred salary, make him the Captain, and the fan base will be happy. Hal won't have to tear down the Judges Chambers. It may be a bad deal for the Yankees 5 years down the road, but I just don't see too many great free agents for next year that the Yankees would go after except maybe another starter. And they can always get some wiggle room by trading dead weights like Hicks and Torres. :)!

And yet another Judge thread... Seriously??:confused:

[QUOTE=Chris Lyle;18437170]And yet another Judge thread... Seriously??:confused:[/QUOTE]

The first 100 weren't enough

[QUOTE=fulltritty;18437132]I honestly think he's going to stay a Yankee. Cashman and Judge will meet somewhere in the middle on salary, offer lots of incentives or maybe some deferred salary, make him the Captain, and the fan base will be happy. Hal won't have to tear down the Judges Chambers. It may be a bad deal for the Yankees 5 years down the road, but I just don't see too many great free agents for next year that the Yankees would go after except maybe another starter. And they can always get some wiggle room by trading dead weights like Hicks and Torres. :)![/QUOTE]


I disagree - Judge will not meet the Yankees in the middle. He will take what he is worth which is why he didn’t take the 7/$213m they offered him in the off season. Judge will get $300M+ in my opinion.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It’s amazing - if people don’t want to see another Judge thread, don’t read it. It’s that simple [emoji2369]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[QUOTE=wharfrat7624;18437181]It’s amazing - if people don’t want to see another Judge thread, don’t read it. It’s that simple [emoji2369]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk[/QUOTE]

Isn't it normal for people to call out another thread on the same subject? Sorry it seems to be normal behavior here..

[QUOTE=wharfrat7624;18437177]I disagree - Judge will not meet the Yankees in the middle. He will take what he is worth which is why he didn’t take the 7/$213m they offered him in the off season. [B]Judge will get $300M+ in my opinion.[/B]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk[/QUOTE]

And that very well could be the new middle in a new Yankees offer. Believe me, after this season, I don't expect the Yankees to re-offer 7 years/$213m unless they really don't want him part of the team.

We don't know yet.

This would be the perfect candidate for Arte Morono to toss 500 mill at, but hopefully he wont be in charge

The Yankees will let him go, sign someone like Nimmo and then to make up for the power, trade for Miguel Sano as a platoon partner of sorts at first base / DH.

Ohtani is hoping someone offers him 45 mil per so he can ask for 65

He’ll set the AL record this year and then will sign with the Giants and go after Bonds.

[QUOTE=BigL7370;18437300]The Yankees will let him go, sign someone like Nimmo and then to make up for the power, trade for Miguel Sano as a platoon partner of sorts at first base / DH.[/QUOTE]

I hate how correct this could be...

[QUOTE=mallowciraptor;18437473]I hate how correct this could be...[/QUOTE]

They budgeted 200 something million for him. I doubt they're going to budget another 100-200m more for him now.

[QUOTE=Triple B;18437464]He’ll set the AL record this year and then will sign with the Giants and go after Bonds.[/QUOTE]

He’s going to have to up his dosing in the off-season if he wants to surpass Bonds.

How many times have we seen: career year during a final contract year? Just to be followed up w/ back down to their career averages or worse?

[QUOTE=JeremyNick;18437479]He’s going to have to up his dosing in the off-season if he wants to surpass Bonds.[/QUOTE]


[IMG]https://i.postimg.cc/cCkwCs0V/larmstrongy.jpg[/IMG]

For 500 million.

Judge and Ohtani will lead the 2023 Giants to a second place finish in the NL West.

I mean...they have to pay him! Especially if they win the WS.

10 years, 500M, Captain

Never heard of him….same guy from the other threads?

There’s never enough Bird threads on here.

My guess: Stays a Yankee, 6/275 1st offer (leaked), signs 6/290

Fully of the belief will stay a yankee if they make a competitive offer.

[QUOTE=rainmaker;18439038]Fully of the belief will stay a yankee if they make a competitive offer.[/QUOTE]

He ain't taking a hometown discount.

You think he chases the $ wherever that ends up? I’m not so sure…. Doing what he’s doing in New York has sone pretty massive perks worth more than say 2mm additional per year on what will surely be a massive offer.

85 % stays with Yankees
10 % Goes to Seattle - They have money and will not be afraid to spend.
5% Goes to Dodgers - If they can't resign the Turner Brothers (Trea & Justin) and Kershaw

[QUOTE=rainmaker;18439057]You think he chases the $ wherever that ends up? I’m not so sure…. Doing what he’s doing in New York has sone pretty massive perks worth more than say 2mm additional per year on what will surely be a massive offer.[/QUOTE]

I don't think he bet on himself just to narrow down his options to only the Yankees.

Dodgers for sure.

[QUOTE=base set;18439022]There’s never enough Bird threads on here.

My guess: Stays a Yankee, 6/275 1st offer (leaked), signs 6/290[/QUOTE]

I could see it getting to $300 million. People saying 10 years are morons.

Signs with Red Sox and I laugh harder than Henry Hill

I'll just call it now...
Mets
$50+ Mil a year
4 Year Deal
Opt out option after 2 years

[QUOTE=SupermanBrandon;18440408]I'll just call it now...
Mets
$50+ Mil a year
4 Year Deal
Opt out option after 2 years[/QUOTE]

I like this for the Mets!
Judge in orange and blue.
Can you envision Judge/Alonso?
Boo-yah!

Megastars do not leave the Yankees in free agency. Only players in poverty franchises do that.

Maybe he wants to sign with a team that has a better chance of winning........

[QUOTE=theshowandme;18440551]Megastars do not leave the Yankees in free agency. Only players in poverty franchises do that.[/QUOTE]


First time for everything


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[QUOTE=SupermanBrandon;18440408]I'll just call it now...
Mets
$50+ Mil a year
4 Year Deal
Opt out option after 2 years[/QUOTE]

Judge ain't taking no 4 year BS deal this is his 1 big payday and 4 won't cut it minimum of 7 around 350

[QUOTE=NYRE2PECT;18436873]Did he fart? I gots to know.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk[/QUOTE]

Right in the catchers face…it smelled of Billy Martins old hats!

[QUOTE=theshowandme;18440551]Megastars do not leave the Yankees in free agency. Only players in poverty franchises do that.[/QUOTE]

He will sign with the team that gives the longest term contract at the most money if you think anything else you don't follow the history of baseball. Obviously if a perennial doormat like Pittsburgh offers the most money then he will probably sign for less but that's about it.

[QUOTE=theshowandme;18440551]Megastars do not leave the Yankees in free agency. Only players in poverty franchises do that.[/QUOTE]

Robinson Cano was a big name that left. Was on a HOF pace, with the help of Steroids :flex:

Still debatable!

Hal is going to have to pay the man or risk empty stands next year. No one is going to watch the crap old players these guys will trot out including Stanton, Hicks, Donaldson, and Rizzo and watch the plummeting they'll take in the standings without Judge.

No way he leaves NYY. They will work a deal eventually. He wants to be a Yankee is the main thing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[QUOTE=SupermanBrandon;18437488]How many times have we seen: career year during a final contract year? Just to be followed up w/ back down to their career averages or worse?[/QUOTE]

This is exactly what I am expecting to happen. Huge contract, spends a decent amount of time next year on the dl..maybe 30hrs

How many judges would Aaron Judge judge, if Aaron Judge could judge judges?

[QUOTE=dbackschamp2001;18469135]How many judges would Aaron Judge judge, if Aaron Judge could judge judges?[/QUOTE]

...62

It comes down to what Judge wants. A good proxy is Trout's contract. He has 296m for 8 left. Does Judge want more than that?

[QUOTE=JRX;18469176]It comes down to what Judge wants. A good proxy is Trout's contract. He has 296m for 8 left. Does Judge want more than that?[/QUOTE]Think more Max Scherzer $$ I'm guessing is what he will get

Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk

[QUOTE=dbackschamp2001;18469135]How many judges would Aaron Judge judge, if Aaron Judge could judge judges?[/QUOTE]

Judging by Judge, I’ll say .083 Judges

[QUOTE=Bars and Bar;18502041]Judging by Judge, I’ll say .083 Judges[/QUOTE]

Alright, this is getting kinda weird now.

[QUOTE=pewe;18437124]Judge: please come home to San Francisco. THANK YOU![/QUOTE]

Fixed.

Sign with the Angels!!!!

[QUOTE=speedyjg13;18502057]Sign with the Angels!!!![/QUOTE]

Nah, he wNts to win. Didn't the angels learn from pujols? He will look good as an ASTRO

Before this playoffs I would have said no doubt about it, now I am leaning towards no unless the Yankees have a miracle comeback, if the Giants or maybe another team offer him more than the Yankees I think he is going to go there.

After listening to the Yankee faithful boo their own team and also boo their MVP and the guy who had the first 60+ HR season in 20 years, I'd not be surprised if Judge hit the road. What terrible fans.

Dodgers really need a slugger. They might be too moneyball to make an offer though.

[QUOTE=TheWiz98;18502254]Dodgers really need a slugger. They might be too moneyball to make an offer though.[/QUOTE]

Re-sign Gallo.

As a Sox fan, I'd like to see Judge in SF or BOS.

[QUOTE=speedyjg13;18502057]Sign with the Angels!!!![/QUOTE]

That literally works out for nobody

[QUOTE=rman112;18502256]Re-sign Gallo.[/QUOTE]How could you. He's a Dodger fan in fragile state.

Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk

I think it's disgusting how Yankees fans have booed Judge during the playoffs. He had an all-time great season this year and carried the team offensively when the rest of the lineup struggled in the second half.

[QUOTE=fabiani12333;18502501]I think it's disgusting how Yankees fans have booed Judge during the playoffs. He had an all-time great season this year and carried the team offensively when the rest of the lineup struggled in the second half.[/QUOTE]

I am not in the least bit interested in Judge.